Malcolm Turnbull’s dubious list of ‘achievements’
High fives and big smiles all round as the Turnbull government completes another year full of achievement – or so the Liberal Party talking points say.
Yesterday I had a look at Tony Abbott’s achievements whilst PM. Today it’s Malcolm’s turn, once again, using the handy list provided by the Liberal Party.
Malcolm’s first listed achievement ironically underlines the division in the government – “An innovation and science agenda to help create the jobs of the future.”
For starters, how can an “agenda” be counted as an achievement?
This agenda/achievement has been roundly blamed for almost costing them the election. Malcolm’s slogan didn’t have the same ring as Axe the Tax and Stop the Boats. There was nothing to get angry about.
Tony Abbott echoed the feelings of many of his colleagues when he said, on November 27, “It is good we’re no longer talking about innovation and agility.”
Achievement number 2 is “Landmark reform of Australia’s competition law – to help small to medium companies compete with big business.”
As far as I am aware, this is still only at the draft legislation stage. No achievement yet.
His next two ‘achievements’ relate to defence spending commitments – “The 2016 Defence White Paper which will secure Australia in the 21st century” and “A defence industry plan which backs local advanced manufacturing, particularly in regional Australia.” So we have a white paper and a plan to spend a lot of money on armaments. Achievement? Not so far.
Number 5 is “Taking action to address domestic violence through the $100 million Women’s Safety Package.”
About $30 million of that funding is for front-line legal assistance and family law services which falls far short of replacing the $52 million the Coalition cut from community legal centres, Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander legal services and legal aid services.
In 2014, police recorded 95 homicides from family and domestic violence-related offences, 3074 victims of family and domestic violence-related sexual assault, and tens of thousands of physical violence cases, and these were only the ones reported to police. How much do we spend on “the war on terror” and how many victims has it claimed in Australia?
Malcolm’s sixth achievement is “Overseeing the release of all children from onshore immigration detention (which compares with Labor’s record of 8,469 children in detention).”
Note the omission of children in offshore detention and the gratuitous and misleading shot at Labor? The number of children in detention was 1,165 at the end of September 2013 and was about 2,000 at its highest.
According to the DIBP, as of October 30 this year, there were still 45 children in detention on Nauru, 5 children in mainland detention, 251 children in community detention, and 4,021 children languishing on bridging visas.
Malcolm’s next ‘achievement’ tells us that he is “Cracking down on multinational tax avoidance to ensure companies that make money in Australia pay tax in Australia.”
As we have heard in a plethora of reports, companies are not paying tax in Australia and, what’s more, we are going to reward their tax avoidance with a 5% tax cut. Great expertise and experience was lost when thousands of jobs were cut from the ATO and belated rehiring of a few of them will not replace it. Likewise, giving back a fraction of the money and jobs that Abbott cut from corporate watchdog ASIC does not give them the resources to adequately do their job.
Then we move on to the Free Trade Agreements.
Can “Legislating to implement the China-Australia Free Trade Agreement” be counted as a Turnbull achievement when he did nothing towards it other than vote?
And does “Signing the Trans-Pacific Partnership” count as an achievement when it hasn’t been agreed to? It hasn’t delivered any “substantial new trade and investment opportunities for Australian businesses” yet that I am aware of, let alone any jobs or income. It’s just another piece of paper at this stage.
The ex-Communications Minister’s list of achievements does not mention the NBN, and nor should it, but it does mention “Bringing our media laws into the digital age and ensuring local media outlets remain viable.”
Once again, this is just a proposal, not an achievement. It appears certain to concentrate media ownership even further, lessen diversity significantly, and mean the end of regional programming.
The Conversation’s analysis of the proposal sounded a warning.
“There is a pressing need to rethink policy and regulation in light of the ongoing transformations surrounding digital convergence. Traditional sector-based approaches to media policy are being challenged. But diversity and pluralism remain policies of high consequence because they are directed at maintaining an informed population.”
We will be increasingly informed by Rupert Murdoch and his minions.
Malcolm is proud of “Establishing the $1 billion Clean Energy Innovation Fund.”
The gall of this is staggering. Firstly, the $1 billion has been taken from the existing, and profitable, Clean Energy Finance Corporation and just called a new name. On top of that, as part of the Omnibus Bill, the Coalition wanted to strip $1 billion in funds from ARENA. In September, Labor eventually agreed to them cutting $500 million after previously agreeing to a significant reduction in the renewable energy target.
The next great achievement was “Banning excessive surcharges on credit cards to protect Australian consumers.”
Merchants can still charge surcharges for using a credit card, they just can’t be “excessive”. Conveniently, no-one has actually defined excessive, but you may save a dollar or two on airline and concert tickets which was probably being illegally charged in the first place if the ACCC had the staff to follow it up.
And it wouldn’t be Malcolm without some public transport – “Investing in important public transport projects, including the $95 million Gold Coast Light Rail, the Sydney Metro and the Melbourne Metro.”
In return for the privatisation of the NSW electricity network and the Port of Melbourne, the Sydney Metro rail project will receive $1.7 billion in federal funding and the Melbourne Metro rail project will receive $857 million from the Federal Government.
Victorian Treasurer Tim Pallas said his state was always expecting to receive the money for the Melbourne Metro.
“This payment is the state’s entitlement, it’s not a gift for Scott Morrison to disperse wherever he pleases,” Mr Pallas said. “This money is money the Commonwealth owes the state for the lease of the Port of Melbourne. This is not new funding.”
And whilst Malcolm did offer $95 million for the Gold Coast Light Rail, it is projected to cost $700 million to build the 7.3 km line for the Commonwealth Games.
Next, Malcolm reminds us of his “Senate voting reform that ensures Australians, not preference whisperers, choose their Senators.”
Combined with an, as it turns out, unnecessary double dissolution, this replaced Glenn Lazarus and Ricky Muir with people like Malcolm Roberts and Rod Culleton and made Pauline Hanson think she has authority.
The last achievement on the list is “The abolition of Bill Shorten’s truck tribunal which was putting owner-operator truck drivers out of business.”
The RSRT was created after the National Transport Commission found in 2008 that there was a link between driver remuneration and safety outcomes for truck drivers and recommended a national scheme to set minimum safe rates for employee and owner drivers.
Once again, the Conversation issues a warning about its abolition.
It is not surprising that some owner drivers are anxious about this payment order … These drivers are probably among the most poorly remunerated in the industry and have extensive debt wrapped up in their trucks. Many are making a marginal living at best.
However, this situation cannot go on forever. Their situation will not improve until the supermarket chains, product manufacturers and other organisations at the top starting negotiating decent pay into their contracts. If the RSRT is abolished, these corporations will continue to avoid responsibility.
Malcolm’s latest achievements – the Registered Organisations Bill, the ABCC and the backpacker’s tax – haven’t made it onto the list yet.
The take home message from those pieces of horse-trading is that we could have avoided an election if the Coalition had been prepared to negotiate in the first place, and that they would rather have higher taxes and lose one or two hundred million from the budget bottom line than agree with Labor.
Aside from an agenda and some proposals and claiming credit for other people’s work, Malcolm has spent most of his time giving back just a little of what Tony Abbott took away.
Like what we do at The AIMN?
You’ll like it even more knowing that your donation will help us to keep up the good fight.
Chuck in a few bucks and see just how far it goes!
Your contribution to help with the running costs of this site will be gratefully accepted.
You can donate through PayPal or credit card via the button below, or donate via bank transfer: BSB: 062500; A/c no: 10495969
22 comments
Login here Register here-
Ella -
Max Gross -
strobedriver -
Miriam English -
LOVO -
Graeme Henchel -
Matters Not -
Clean livin -
George Swalwell -
wam -
Michael Taylor -
LOVO -
bobrafto -
Matters Not -
Shogan -
Wayne Turner -
Ella -
townsvilleblog -
Jack Straw -
Kaye Lee -
Jack Straw -
bob
Return to home pageKaye Lee, congratulations….another piece worth while reading.
“Malcolm has spent most of his time giving back just a little of what Tony Abbott took away”
We are indeed living in “post truth times” when a PM can claim as achievements issues that have not eventuated and are no more than proposals.
Which is what he managed to do to SA in relation to the Murray Darling….and they fell for it.
All talk and no action.
So we had Mr. Abbott who headed the most destructive administration, followed by Mr. Turnbull an ineffective administration, all talk and no action.
Achievements, eh? Well, Mal, I guess it’s just all downhill from here!
Excellent and succinct article, especially from the perspective of the ‘war on terror’ which resides in the Howard/Bush era which has long been derided as a farce and yet another chance to go to war with ‘brown people’; and cost the Australian population a despicable amount of money/time/energy on a falsehood. One however, thatt seems unbelievably, to still hold some sway within the populace as it is continually resuscitated. Better that, than concentrate on the economy I suppose — very Putin. Well done Ms Lee for your insightful interlinking..
Important piece Kaye. I wish the mainstream media would publish articles like this.
Julia Gillard just looks better and better as time goes by. *sigh*
Mayhap Mal should of noted his possible reintroduction of an Carbon Price as an achievement.
What is it with RWingers and thier rank hypocrisy, lies and distortions.
Great work KL….they can only fool some of the people, mm.
Who can give a smile while he’s telling you a lie
It’s the Fizza, it’s the Fizza
Who can Latin quote as he treats you like a dope
It’s the Fizza, it’s the Fizza
Chorus
The Fizza has sold his soul for the prize
The Fizza now speaks in slogans and lies
The Fizza has shown that he’s got no balls
The Fizza cares ’bout the Fizza that’s all
Who gets on the train just to make himself look plain
It’s the Fizza, it’s the Fizza
Who shakes fists a lot as he talks a load of rot
It’s the Fizza, it’s the Fizza
Who’s swung to the right cos they have his balls so tight
It’s the Fizza, it’s the Fizza
Who will make the claim that it’s labor thats to blame
It’s the Fizza, it’s the Fizza
Who was a banker and is always a wanker
It’s the Fizza, it’s the Fizza
Who is going down, just like the last lying clown
It’s the Fizza, it’s the Fizza
True. In the last Budget, provision was made for an additional 100 staff. Necessary? Perhaps – but certainly not sufficient. As tax experts point out time and again, the tax avoidance engaged in is ‘legal’. Perfectly legitimate in the eyes of the law. Indeed, any Board which ignores their fiduciary duty and doesn’t explore and exploit those perfectly legal avenues is in legal trouble.
The point being that the current legal regimes are completely inadequate. Nothing of substance will change unless there’s significant changes to the legal framework. The LNP should embrace the legal amendments proposed by Labor to close loopholes and the like – except such proposals are simply not there. There’s no point of difference
But Labor could go much further. What’s the problem with making Directors, CEOs and others personally responsible when illegalities are established? Corporations can’t be jailed (only fined – legitimate business expenses and all that). Perhaps that ‘escape’ clause might be closed for those who actually authorised or ignored legal obligations. The potential to jail high profile offenders is guaranteed to change behavior. And quickly.
In China, for example, they don’t concentrate on ‘corporations’ they sheet responsibility home to individuals. You do the crime, you do the time. That’s how it should be.
Just imagine, Gerry visiting Rupert once a week in the slammer to recharge his pacemaker.
None can beat Billy McMahons decision not to make a decision.
Spin, exaggeration, double-talk, even obfuscation (now that’s a good Malcolm-esque
word, meaning to obscure, bewilder, stupify) – a good example of Liberal talking up of
nothing much into “achievements”.
The double dissolution has painted Malcolm into a corner, and One Nation is ready
and willing to stir things up regularly.
fab read as usual how sad to see the hard working learners muir and lazarus go and the twits take their place.
I was starting to like Muir, wam. At first I thought he’d stumble and fall. I was wrong. He definitely stood up. Morrison pulled the wool over his eyes – once – but he didn’t let it happen again.
Thanx for that “visualisation” MN re: Gerry and the pacemaker….eww comes to mind… ima guessing once you have had a strolling bone… etc and such……jest sayin’ 😯
P.S. By the way did I mention eww….
We will be increasingly informed by Rupert Murdoch and his minions.
https://www.theguardian.com/media/2016/dec/06/michelle-guthrie-murdoch-consultant-restructure-abc-jim-rudder
Michele Guthrie is only doing what she was appointed to do – further integrate the ABC into the NEWS empire.
Predictable, and predicted. No surprises.
Actually, she’s doing rather well. And ahead of schedule to boot.
Next on the list will be SBS.
If Malcolm Turnbull’s dubious list of ‘achievements’ were ever released in a book it would certainly be put on the Fiction Shelves on the day of release & then transferred to the Remainders Display out the front of the shop on the second day.
As I kept saying about the government’s May Budget & Election Campaign Manifesto, it was just a list of HEADLINES in search of stories to give them some semblance of substance!!
Can anyone supply any evidence of stories that give some semblance of substance to the following CORE HEADLINES?
– Jobs and Growth
– An Innovation and Science Agenda
– Crack down on Multinational Tax Avoidance
Can anyone supply any evidence of progress for the CORE HEADLINES??
No achievements,but plenty of lies,and of course the cop out of blaming Labor.
Kaye Lee,
I have just been reading the IPA’s wish list of 75 items .It would be interesting to examine both Mr. Abbott’s and Mr. Turnbull’s list of achievements and see how closely they follow this wish list . Also the negative and positive impact of putting the wish list into policy.
Another beautiful piece of writing from Kaye, the LNP are focusing on what they consider the positive, completely ignoring that they have taken most of the benefits away from “the people” yet their budget deficit has blown from the $19 bn they inherited to $40 bn in only 3 years, they have been absolutely hopeless managers of Australia’s public finances, and the poorest Australian have paid the highest price with now 3 million of a population of 24 million living in poverty, bloody disastrous.
I have little sympathy for the two bob tories, working people who vote LNP against their own class, and end up being a victim of the LNP mismanagement of our economy by suddenly finding themselves in the unemployment ques.
I watched Federal Minister Matt Canavan speak yesterday at the approval of the Adani mines project in Qld. I have watched this nasty man speak a few times and I am never impressed with him. And people could have heard me cry you “Bullshitting Wanker” from a few doors down this when he describe the project as being a wonderful “Economical Ecosystem”.
Assets and Liabilities
The net worth of the General Government sector is a negative net asset position of $205,908 million at
31 August 2013. The net debt of the General Government sector is $161,253 million at 31 August 2013.
https://www.finance.gov.au/sites/default/files/mfs-july-august-2013.pdf?v=3
Assets and Liabilities
As at 31 October 2016:
• Net worth is negative $434,748 million;
• Net debt is $313,971 million; and
• Net financial liabilities are $608,264 million.
https://www.finance.gov.au/sites/default/files/mfs-october_2016_0.pdf
I also heard the treasurer Scott Morrison speak with fairdinkummate Ray Hadley yesterday.Scott was speaking as if he didn’t have a care in the world.Ray was playing good cop on this day. I am now certain that 2GB runs the country. The Liberal puppets take their orders from Jones and co.
i like tony abott better