Information and critical thinking do matter

By 2353NM  When Prime Minister Morrison was advised there was the risk of…

The Coronavirus Republic: Three Million Infections and Rising

The United States is famed for doing things, not to scale, but…

How The Black Lives Matter Protest Enables Me…

It seems that Dan Andrews has stuffed up by allowing a protest…

Leadership and popularity

[Terry Mills has defended his fracking flip-flop, saying he doesn’t believe the…

Netanyahu’s Annexation Drive

Land seizures, annexations, and conquest. These are words axiomatic to the state…

COVID-19: Where was it born: China, the United…

Continued from: COVID-19: Where was it born: China, the United States or…

Government's inaction on young workers’ struggles having abhorrent…

By William Olson  A recent run of statistics regarding Australia’s young people in…

New study sparks fresh call for seagrass preservation

Edith Cowan University Media ReleaseAn increase in carbon dioxide emissions equivalent to…

«
»
Facebook

To the Commercial Heavens We Go! SpaceX, NASA and Space Privatisation

It would be too simple to regard the latest space venture, funded by Elon Musk, as entirely a matter of vast ego and deeply-pocked adventurism. But it would be close. The successful delivery of astronauts Douglas Hurley and Robert Behnken of NASA as part of the joint mission with SpaceX to the International Space Station by the Dragon capsule proved intoxicating for followers and devotees. Behnken was himself keen on the idea of travelling into the heavens away from a messy, trouble-torn planet. “This is still something that we are going to be successful at, and we’re going to do it in the face of the pandemic.” Good of him to think so.

The theme of inspiration in the face of terrestrial disaster is a mammoth one, even if that inspiration tends to avoid earthbound maladies. “If SpaceX can pull it off,” wrote an enthralled Miriam Kramer for Axios, “its first crewed flight … will mark a beacon of hope in an otherwise dark time for the world.”

The element of chest-thumping was always going to be hard to avoid. Since 2011, NASA has been relying, with occasional reluctance, on Russia’s Soyuz rockets to get to the International Space Station. The Space Shuttle programme had become extortionately expensive, ballooning to $1.5 bn a flight. The razor gangs took issue. The private sector, in other words, has been used to extract US astronauts from the Russian teat. Those at NASA were thrilled in the announcement. “This is the first time in human history [NASA astronauts] have entered the Space Station from a commercially made spacecraft.”

Kramer is unsparing in her praise for the effort. It is all patriotism and, as with all things patriotic, silly in its competitiveness. Despite any intimations of a broader human purpose (from universe to universal), this was done for US interests. “The space program has provided this kind of hope during dark times before.” A few unfortunate reminders are furnished, including the reading of the book of Genesis by those in the orbiting Apollo 8 capsule on Christmas Eve 1968 “as millions of people watched back on Earth.”

As this was done, the US was also fracturing, bloodied by political assassination (Martin Luther King, Jr. and Robert Kennedy), anti-war protest and racial unrest. No resolution seemed in sight, at least in the country, so a distracting focus was found. One of the Apollo 8 crew, Frank Borman, remembered a telegram he and his colleagues received on landing, a true pearler amongst the millions. “Congratulations to the crew of Apollo 8. You saved 1968.”

This was merely a soppy aside. During the 1960s, the sceptics gathered and lectured humanity for finding escape from more terrestrial ills which demanded their attention. Humans were making a mess of things and looking to the skies. English historian Arnold J. Toynbee had little time for such matters. “In a sense, going to the moon is like building pyramids or Louis XIV’s palace at Versailles. It’s rather scandalous, when human beings are going short of necessities, to do this. If we’re clever enough to reach the moon, don’t we feel rather foolish in our mismanagement of human affairs?”

The sentiment has not changed much, depending on where you are looking for it. The rot is very much there, and the eyes are looking elsewhere. Renewable energy advocate Giles Parkinson sees it all as silly extra-terrestrial expenditure, ignoring the obvious problems facing Planet Earth. “Money that’s thrown at things like space travel, and exploration for oil and gas – that’s money that could also be spent on addressing the climate change issue.”

Musk stands for a different attitude. Renewables and space are mere ends to be exploited. He intends cluttering space with 11,943 satellites by 2025, with the hope of putting a total of 42,000. Like any egomaniac, he must make this all sound purposeful, wrapping it in the rhetoric of the “multi-planetary” society that intends to give every human on Planet Earth speedy Internet access.

Such projects as Musk’s are bound to, and have already interested, the military-industrial complex. Whatever gloss of achievement given, space is very much like the Americas for Christopher Columbus, to be acquired, consumed, and plundered.  Commercialism, industry, and the armed forces are all converging into a soufflé of interests that will carve the heavens for military commanders, egomaniacs and space buccaneers. Very notably, SpaceX is drawing in its defence contracts.  

It continues to woo and impress the talking heads with more guns than butter. In 2016, the launch and retrieval by Musk’s company of its Falcon 9 first-stage booster once it had done its job, namely placing a satellite into orbit, induced perorations of praise. “Until now,” as Jeffrey Becker wrote at the time, “getting into orbit meant throwing away most of the rocket on the way up in order to place a minute fraction of the total vehicle mass into space, an approach to spaceflight akin to throwing away a 747 after crossing the Atlantic.”

From a human perspective, the latest SpaceX venture may not have been as enthralling as others. There was little in the way of romance, and much in the way of brattish bravado from Musk. But make no mistake about it. The commercial world is stretching its corporate tentacles into space, and wishes to go a very long way.

Like what we do at The AIMN?

You’ll like it even more knowing that your donation will help us to keep up the good fight.

Chuck in a few bucks and see just how far it goes!

Donate Button

4 comments

Login here Register here
  1. Jane Salmon

    Pretty tempted by the notion of firing all billionaires at the sun.

    If it was only to Mars, they’d come back.

  2. Phil Pryor

    A highly polished knob as a reserve mirror could be used to attract solar rays for further electricity generation by the rich defective…but dreams have often had side effects, good and bad, so is the money wasted? Is the ethics “safe”? Why bother? (it’s out there…)

  3. Ken Fabian

    Any industry that relies almost entirely on government contracts does not look like free enterprise to me and the hype and self congratulation is out of proportion.

    Only communications and ground sensing, entirely for Earth based needs, has ever rated as “commercial” – and even that requires leaving aside the long history of taxpayer R&D efforts that companies including SpaceX tapped into, built on and didn’t have to pay for. I am not convinced SpaceX could afford it’s private commercial ambitions to put 10’s of thousands of satellites, for a global internet, without the money that comes directly or indirectly from taxpayers, let alone afford Mars. There is legitimate scientific interest in Mars for potential evidence of life other than Terrestrial – something healthy wealthy Earth nations can afford to pursue – but it is not and has never been a reasonable target for human colonisation.

    None of the grand space dreams – Moon or Mars colonies, asteroid mines, space manufacturing, space habitats – has ever looked even remotely like able to stand on their own finances or capable of delivering commercial returns to private investors, let alone “bootstrap” itself into growth. Over the 60 plus years of chasing those grand dreams the “great opportunities” have still not become apparent.

  4. Southern Sailor

    I have nothing but admiration for Musk and marvel at his achievements. Whether his ventures and exploits are worthy, especially in the face of such developing trauma for humanity down here on Terra Firma, is a hotly debated set of issues.

    Yes, he may seem a brattish overexuberent classic yank billionaire, but I think the measure of a man like him is not the marketing or the hype, it’s the results, and, in reflecting on those, the viability of his futuristic dreams for us.

    I read up on his creation of spacex, and it is nothing short of amazing. He has taken off the shelf gear, reworked and tweaked much of it and he and his engineers have created heavy lift Earth orbiting rockets, all on a shoestring budget, in a fraction of the time and cost and with at least the reliability of NASA. In fact, NASA must be embarrassed by his success.

    If Musk is not an alien sent here to pull humanity out of the shit, then he must be another Einstein, but with multiple engineering degrees. Just about anything he turns his hand to is a stunning success. Take Tesla for example. Having developed and re-engineered battery powered car drive trains to a level that the major car manufacturers could only dream existed in some ideal universe, Musk then made the designs open source and free, yes, any one could copy his designs into commercial products with his blessing. Reason? He wants us to move away from fossil fuels and the tyranny of big oil and coal. Musk wants to take us all with him.

    Look at all his projects, Neuralink to help disabled people by giving them machine interface to replace defective bodies, Boring Co. to provide an alternative to high cost air travel and reduce the carbon footprint, Solar City developing commercial and residential solar power generation. All these ideas come to fruition, Musk delivers on his promises, and they all benefit humanity now, and incalculably into the future.

    Sure, the whole Mars, Moon space thing seems far fetched and overly ambitious, and if we want to do it we’ll need more than Stanley Kubrick this time. But if there is someone who can get us there then it would be Musk. If there is a way to make it profitable it will be Musk. Who knows, he may be right about being prudent by creating a colony off Earth, and insulating ourselves from destruction due to some calamity, like a virus, or global warming tipping point or that good old ripper, nuclear holocaust. I can see his point. We are sitting on enough nukes to turn the planet into radioactive glass, many, many times over and the world is ruled by Machiavellian nut jobs. That is the legacy of governments of all persuasions, that is the hellish nightmare and pinnacle of civilisation’s achievements so far – so why not give ourselves another roll of the dice? Go Musk.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Return to home page
Scroll Up
%d bloggers like this: