Swiftie Nonsense Down Under

Gaza. Palestinians. Israel. Genocide. Taylor Swift? This odd cobbling of words is…

New research highlights the growing prevalence and economic…

New research by the e61 Institute presents five facts on the use…

Ok, So This Is A Boring Post... Or…

Gloria Sty, bud Iyam riting this coz I wanna mayk sum poynts…

Border Paranoia in Fortress Australia

The imaginative faculties of standard Australian politicians retreat to some strange, deathly…

Where the Palestine laboratory takes us all

By Antony Loewenstein Israel's war on Gaza since 7 October has caused the…

No, no, no, no. Not more ‘illegals’!

By Bert Hetebry A group of South Asian men arrived on our doorstep…

Rafah, Gaza: Urgent Statement from CEOs of Humanitarian…

Oxfam Media Release We are appalled by the harrowing developments in Rafah, Gaza’s…

Joe Biden: The Damnation of Age

He was sweet and well meaning, but he was old. He was…


Magic money

By 2353NM

Naturally enough in the wake of the catastrophic bushfires that have affected most states since last October, there has been a national discussion on theories that, according to their proponents, would have reduced the risk of bushfires starting or would allow us to more effectively attack the raging bushfires if implemented.

Some of the theories have been simply crazy. The ‘greenies’ are claimed to have a policy that prohibits hazard reduction burns. No one has ever produced a copy of this policy, in all likelihood because it doesn’t exist. Even if the mythical policy did exist, the Greens don’t have enough representation at any level of government to make the policy into legislation without the assistance of at least one of the two major political parties — or to enforce it.

Sadly, another myth is Morrison’s claimed financial assistance to volunteers that have been called into action over the summer. While the ‘headline’ sounded good, the ‘headline’ is a fallacy.

While an incredibly small minority of the fires were caused through malicious activity a lot of them were caused by lightning and other natural causes. That’s where climate change comes in. The ferocity of the blazes and the speed that they travel, burning vegetation and man-made objects that have dried out due to a lack of customary rain is a direct result of climate change. Spring 2019 was the driest on record. The 6 hottest Australian days on record were all in December 2019.

While hazard reduction burns are a successful tool in the reduction of the severity of bushfires, the problem is that changing environmental factors significantly reduce the timeframes available for safely completing those burns.

Professor David Bowman, director of the Fire Centre Research Hub at the University of Tasmania, said it was becoming harder to carry out preventive burns.

Professor Bowman said there were risks to preventive burning and fire agencies were limited by things like weather.

“The weather windows are shrinking and if you burn in the wrong conditions you can also smoke out cities and create ill health,”

So it’s probably not a surprise that the planned hazard reduction burns in a number of Australian states fell short of the plan last year — they just ran out of resources and time. Regardless of how ‘nicely’ we talk to the climate you can probably bet that it won’t change anything, so the only other option is to determine a way to complete the burns on a shorter timeframe — which inevitably involves more resources, and money to pay for the resources. Experts are saying we need a five-fold increase in funding for hazard reduction burns. They’re probably right, experts usually are.

Money is the problem here. Governments of all persuasions have offered carrots of tax cuts to various groups of people for years with the hidden stick of a reduction in services that is hoped won’t be noticed. We have the absurdity of the federal government up until very recently vowing and declaring that a surplus budget is more important that just about anything else (maybe with the exception of family holidays to Hawaii) while refusing to spend money on all sorts of worthwhile projects.

While it’s easy to tell the ‘gummit’ to fix it, we all have to share the blame. State and local governments in particular get their revenue from taxes and charges, and until we have a federal government that understands Modern Monetary Theory, so does the federal government. History tells us we vote for a potential government that will give us all a tax cut (that probably won’t give us the money to buy an extra coffee or chocolate bar each week — but that’s irrelevant apparently) rather than the potential government that is planning to improve services to the public. We also complain about the extra 10 cents per trip on public transport, or the extra $50 on our rates or registration bills, all of which is used to maintain or improve the government services we all use on a daily basis. We are the problem — political parties wouldn’t offer tax cuts rather than services if the electors didn’t lap it up.

Funding hazard reduction burning is primarily a state responsibility. But the $16 million reduction in funding for ABC radio news doesn’t reflect the importance of broadcasting local and relevant information across the regions affected by bushfires this summer despite damage to their own equipment. This isn’t a one off. The ABC has done this in most, if not all, natural disasters that have occurred in Australia in the past 50 years or more. Funding for the ABC is a federal government issue.

We also have a universal medical insurance system called Medicare that didn’t receive an increase in the benefits payable for years — causing some who can’t afford the ‘gap’ payment to postpone or even cancel plans to receive health care in an appropriate timeframe. It is also a concern when this description of the public-school system and facilities in parts of the USA is demonstrably better than public and private schools can do here. Schools are a combined state and federal funding responsibility.

The current federal government is solely responsible for the Centrelink ‘robo-debt’ debacle, through outsourcing and casualisation within the federal public service. They are also responsible for not employing enough people to fix the issue. The loss of corporate memory within the federal public service will come back to haunt us — just as ‘under the table’ cuts to the provision for firefighting equipment and hazard reduction burns has done in the past few months.

It may be the 21st Century, but getting something for nothing is still an illusion if you think about it. So next time a politician promises that ‘everything is awesome’ and we can afford tax cuts for all, maybe we should be collectively asking what funding are you removing from services we all rely on to ‘magic’ the money for the tax cut out of seemingly thin air?

What do you think?

This article was originally published on The Political Sword

For Facebook users, The Political Sword has a Facebook page:
Putting politicians and commentators to the verbal sword

Like what we do at The AIMN?

You’ll like it even more knowing that your donation will help us to keep up the good fight.

Chuck in a few bucks and see just how far it goes!

Donate Button


Login here Register here
  1. DrakeN

    What do I think?

    We are but sheeple, after having been fleeced, we are led “…like lambs to the slaughter”.

    The Unholy Trinity of Finance, Politics and Religions compose the essential ingredients of the “…false prophets…” which the mythical Jesus warned us.

    As well, the ‘dirty minds’ of the past are now less grubby due to the successful brainwashing to which we are continually exposed and the ‘…open minds…’ of which many of the indoctrinators speak and write have indeed allowed many people’s brains to fall out. [see QandA and Jim Molan last Monday.]

    We have been ‘conned’ by the actual forces of evil; and with our willing connivance.

  2. Kerri

    I’ve been screaming for years that we should be paying more in taxes so that public transport can be free for all.
    Maybe more people would use it if they knew they were paying for it anyway??
    And imagine a public transport system that is there for the benefit of the public and runs all night so young people can get home safely??? And goes to all places because that’s what the public need and a real government is bound to provide!
    In essence our taxes should pay for anything we can’t, as individuals, afford to cover or organise to undertake.
    If we had to each pay for the roads we want to use or hospitals we need life would be impossible.
    And yet we live in a country where people who can’t really afford that continue to vote for the party that assures that in the future you will have to pay for every freaking thing in your life as well as the shiny asses of politicians who removed from duties such as overseeing policing, health, transport, education etc have nothing left to do but vote on their own pay rises.
    When will this nation wake up? How much of this country are the LNP prepared to sell off for a quick budget boost?
    And when it all turns to s**t and the LNP have nothing left to sell they will promote some imbecile (I’m looking at you Barnaby) as their leader and throw in the whole mess for the responsible adult left wing party/ies to clean up!
    Like they have done before.

  3. Kronomex

    Everything about the LNP is magic money which that will appear if they wave the Friedeggburger Fiscal Wand and say, “Magicus Moneyus from my Arseus.” Or my personal favourite, time travelling money from the future. Dog help us if they ever get their hands on the superannuation treasure chest. Until such time as the magic spells and time travel cash actually works the little people will continue to cop it in the neck because there is no way they will want to upset their corporate paymasters.

  4. pierre wilkinson

    it all comes down to deflection and distraction from the uselessness of thoughts and prayers in our no plan mis-government..
    and let us not mention the cuts to funding across the board, tax cuts for the wealthy who try not to pay tax, hand outs to their mates, tenders for contracts not transparent or contested, privatisation of all services, billions for home affairs
    and as Kronomex so succinctly puts it, the greedy bastards now want to use our superannuation treasure chest

    over two years or just two bi-elections

  5. Andy56

    people just dont understand basic stuff. Would you rather pay $5 in tax or $20 tolls every day? Nope, i would rather a $5 tax cut. Stupid just cant adequately describe them.

  6. wam

    had my yearly oldies assessment , which I passed with a fee mms shorter and only 500gms lighter despite every morning in the pool.Whilst waiting I saw the sign pointing out that if the doctor proscribes an test then you must make an appointment to get the results. The cost will be capped at $60 unless the doctor does more than give you the results.
    Should a pensioner oops a welfare recipient go to the doctor thursday pm the fee is deducted and on friday the oldie goes to centrelink who reimburses the scheduled fee on monday or tuesday leaving the welfare old age recipient short for 3/4 days.
    sounds effing awful to me but I take oldies to vote and they vote conservative because they pay the rent at the 1975 rates and will do unless they shift. They all have two bedroom flats and are uncaring about the current restrictions./
    I shake my head at their beliefs but albo cannot win without a very hard 12 hour day beginning immediately. First is to devise a strategy to negate smiko’s labor are spenders and to destroy the slogan labor and the greens. Please select a candidate willing to start now with the aim to deseat brandt..
    ps just saw a lnp woman say she cannot see how a coal mine caused a bushfire – I screamed because you eat and sleep in straight lines yes no no idea of webs or consequences or questions that require thought.

  7. Pingback: Magic money #newsoz.org #auspol - News Oz

  8. New England Cocky

    @Kerri: The problem the undeserving wealthy and corporates who receive about $160 BILLION in government largesse, free grass and for nothing, in the form of tax deductions, tax credits, concessions and grants that are frequently out-dated for the national interest or, as in the case of the about $9 BILLION per year government subsidies to private schools, straight out vote buying for the aspiring middle class and religious organisations.

    This distortion of the tax base means that PAYE individuals carry almost the full burden of government, rather than both national and multinational corporations who make the most profits from our stable political environment ….. before exporting those profits overseas for the benefit of foreign shareholders.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

The maximum upload file size: 2 MB. You can upload: image, audio, video, document, spreadsheet, interactive, text, archive, code, other. Links to YouTube, Facebook, Twitter and other services inserted in the comment text will be automatically embedded. Drop file here

Return to home page