Manus, Nauru way worse than Pezzullo texts

By Jane Salmon All the hyperbole about Pezzullo's fall from grace is…

From my "To read" list comes nothing but…

Now, how do I tackle this? Do I use the information in…

Cruel Prerogatives: Braverman on Refugees at the AEI

Suella Braverman has made beastliness a trait in British politics. The UK…

Dictator Dan Quits And Victoria Is Free...

With the resignation of Dan Andrews, Victorians can once again go to…

Tech Council of Australia Supports Indigenous Voice to…

Media Alert Canberra: Following the announcement of the referendum date, the Tech Council…

The Legacy of Daniel Andrews: Recognising the Good…

Today the impending retirement of Daniel Andrews – Labor Premier of Victoria…

Study reveals most common forms of coercive control…

Media Release A new study by the NSW Bureau of Crime Statistics and…

Great Expectations from the Summit of the G-77…

By Denis Bright The prospects for commitment to UN General Assembly’s sustainment development…


Budget expectations, honesty and responsibilities

Before Anthony Albanese and his party came to power more than six months ago, the Australian people didn’t know much about the fresh-faced, good-looking young man who has represented the seat of Rankin in the House of Representatives since 2013.

The lead-up to last Tuesday’s Budget had been extraordinary. Dr Jim Chalmers made it almost his daily duty to explain its importance to the nation’s future.

The Treasurer’s mother is a nurse, and his father is a courier driver who left the marriage when Chalmers was 13. He has two older sisters but spent his adolescent nights at home alone because his mother worked the night shift. He says he could quickly have gone off the tracks but for a high school teacher who found a way to reach him.

Before Jim’s election to Parliament, he was the Executive Director of the Chifley Research Centre and Chief of Staff to the Deputy Prime Minister and Treasurer.

He has a PhD in political science and international relations from the Australian National University and a first-class honours degree in public policy from Griffith University. He is a qualified company director and has written two books.

Last Tuesday, Chalmers, to use his term, had his chance to “walk further and forward” when he delivered his and the Government’s first Budget. His nerves early on were understandable, having been Treasurer for only five months. However, he has overseen close to 16 Budgets as a staffer and advisor. One might call him the youngest-ever father of the Budget lockups.

He has known the secretary of the Treasury, Steven Kennedy, for 15 years. Together with his Chief of Staff, Claudia Crawford, they were both at Wayne Swan’s side during the GFC. The Finance Minister, Katy Gallagher, is a friend and colleague. It has been said that being involved in Budget preparation with her is like being “hit in the arse with a rainbow.”

The Treasurer and Finance Minister said before delivering his first ever Budget:

“This budget will be solid, sensible and suited to the times we are in…

This budget is the government’s first opportunity to deliver on our commitments to the Australian community and to begin to clean up the mess left behind by the former Coalition government.” (Jim Chalmers).

“The former government used taxpayers’ money to cynically buy votes before elections by politicising grants funds and used the budget to land political deals with the Nationals in the Coalition party room – that approach to spending ends in Labor’s first budget.” (Katy Gallagher).

Off the top of my head, I listed the following that wanted or needed an increase in their share of the cake: Income support, job seeker allowance, climate change, increase in rental support, disaster mitigation assistance, child poverty, housing, Health, Dental care, education, aged care, aged health dementia, free child care, parental leave scheme, cost of living, charitable institutions, domestic violence, wages, government departments like FIO, mental health, NDIS, suicide, The ABC, defence, The environment, Bureau of metrology. And on top of all that, there is the funding of Labor’s election commitments.

In my memory, it would be the first Budget delivered in a honeymoon period. On top of that, it would be a budget delivered against a backdrop of a possible world recession, global inflation, and environmental disasters. You can add poor leadership around the world to that.

Flood waters running down our east coast continue to rise, inundating crops and property, demoralising communities and adding inflationary pressures.

There is no doubt that the global economy is volatile. We have a budget that is in structural deficit, meaning that we have an imbalance between what we earn and what we spend. We must address this problem in the short term for the good of the long.

In the words of Jim Chalmers:

“I think about it almost every day. How do I take the complexity of the economy and the Budget and not dumb it down but explain it and level with people about what we are grappling with; try and give them the sense that there’s a lot of 50-50 calls in managing the economy. That’s the sense I want to give.”

We are now in the post Budget period, and how the Treasurer has performed with the crucial task of getting the economy back on track is being reviewed. Anyway, if my analysis doesn’t suit you, here are five experts who can help:

David Crowe:

“The devastating line that worked so well for Labor only months ago is now rebounding on Jim Chalmers in a budget that cannot guarantee the most important election promise of all.

“Everything is going up except your wages,” voters were told in a relentless Labor message before the election. “Only Labor has a plan to get wages moving.”

Ross Gittens:

“This Budget is careful with taxpayer funds without embarking on major changes that put Labor’s political capital at risk.

The tough decisions are being put off until May.”

Shane Wright:

“There are no longer four horsemen of the Apocalypse. There are five stubborn donkeys of debt and deficit, and their names are interest, aged care, health, defence and the NDIS.

The 2022-23 redo budget from Jim Chalmers and Katy Gallagher reveals clearly just how the new crew are wreaking havoc through the nation’s finances. Since taking office, they have referenced the five spending donkeys and the long-term financial risk they pose. The Budget confirms the damage.”

Jessica Irvine:

“Australian households hoping for significant cost-of-living “relief” in this Budget will be sorely disappointed.

Chalmers has offered a “five-point plan” to provide “responsible cost-of-living relief”, comprising cheaper childcare, expanded parental leave, cheaper medicines, more affordable housing and getting wages moving again. But households need to prepare for much more short-term pain before this benefit kicks in.”

More from Ross Gittens:

“This “solid and sensible” Budget is not so much good or bad as incomplete. It hints at “hard decisions” to be made but doesn’t make them. Chalmers says it’s “a beginning of the long task of budget repair, not the final destination”.

In the end, all will be revealed. But right now, we’ve been shown little.”

Peter Hartcher:

Dr Jim Chalmers has observed the doctor’s sacred obligation under the Hippocratic oath – do no harm. His mini-budget doesn’t aggravate any of the problems in the economy or the Budget. But it doesn’t do much by way of healing, either.”

It was as I predicted. A clear-the-air budget that sets up the next one and the one after so that continuity is achieved. It will reveal the hard decisions that still need to be made.

We were entitled to an honest appraisal of the actual state of the economy, and that’s what we got. It was open and responsible and revealed the incompetence of the conservative parties.

It told us that we were in a financial mess, but we have good honest people trying to fix the problems.

My thought for the day

The common good, or empathy for it, should be at the centre of any political philosophy. However, it is more likely to be found on the left than the right.


Like what we do at The AIMN?

You’ll like it even more knowing that your donation will help us to keep up the good fight.

Chuck in a few bucks and see just how far it goes!

Your contribution to help with the running costs of this site will be gratefully accepted.

You can donate through PayPal or credit card via the button below, or donate via bank transfer: BSB: 062500; A/c no: 10495969

Donate Button


Login here Register here

    On a personal note, I look at Jim Chalmers, who I believe will be our next Prime Minister in time, and Albo and the people they have around them…….and I relax, even smile, rather than saying “Oh F^%K…..what now?” when seeing Boy Blunder and his stable of unstable sycophants and rorters as with the LNP.

  2. leefe

    Could have been better; could have been one hell of a lot worse.

    Mostly, I think they’ve done the right thing exxcept for those damn promised tax cuts, which have to be dumped because the nation simply can not afford them.

  3. Keitha Granville

    It’s going to be OK, the grownups are back in charge of the bank account, and running the household.
    Nobody can fix this giant pile of crap in one hit, it’s got to be slow and steady.

  4. New England Cocky

    Uhm John Lord ….. why are you quoting known mainstream media-crity toadies for the COALition who appear to regularly re-write political press releases rather than do any investigative journalism?

    The problem with the Budget is not revenue, it is expenditure on the poor people of Australia like foreign owned corporations receiving oil search ”subsidies” to continue polluting the environment, private schools continuing to produce academically inferior kids unable to write an essay or count above 100, tax benefits like negative gearing for residential property owners, defence contracts for weapons that will be long out-dated by the time they are delivered in the future never-never. The list goes on …..

    These are ”the stubborn donkeys of debt and deficit” in the Australian economy continued by unquestioning politicians.

    Perhaps now we have well qualified politicians with specialist study in their ministerial areas of responsibility we will see some change in favour of the Australian egalitarian society that has vanished under the RAbbott-Turdball-Scummo COALition misgovernment of the past nine (9) years.

  5. Clakka

    Yep, apparently responsible and at the same time innocuous. Sort of like ‘wearing moccasins and dragging a branch.’ Leaving a trail for the braying bloodhounds and their keepers’ prognostications. A clever move, provisioning only the matters most pressed-for by women and family managers, and a regulatory de-stagnation to slowly release the bonds tying the working poor – yet most of all buying time to see the actual seasonal effects of the northern hemisphere’s winter of discontent.

    Yet, as if by suspension of gravity, hang so many necessary titanic new-world dreams burgeoning above the darkening clouds, all grasping at a quivering sword of Damocles, as fiscal nightmares. Industrialists and warriors pensive, pent and bound whilst energy ogres run amok lubricating only themselves. Will further inclusions of an insurance scheme suffice? Who knows. Perhaps in defiance of time we can fashion a worm-hole.

    Next year, as we move into the main game, and our own winter, that we might go rugged-up, cap in hand, looking forward to a spring in our step, or be drawing a sword, is surely anybody’s guess.

  6. StephenGB

    Hear hear NEC. Spot on the money (pun not intended) !

    There is some good and some bad in this none budget, which is a little churlish of me to mention, but my small gripe (which disappoints me).

    It actually prioritises the Not so struggling with a sop award or two, whilst awarding the DESPERATELY struggling with NOTHING, ZIP, ZERO, NADA, BUGGA all.

    Clearly there must be a grand plan out there, which I fail to grasp !

    But hey it’s better than another kick from the other lot !

  7. wam

    Yes, lord, AlboChalm are our boys.
    They are not blaming scummo et al for the inflation and feel or at least say they have such empathy for the poor wage earner’s steady slide down the pay scale over the next few years during such huge rises in costs.
    Thank goodness they have organised an extra $9000 for themselves to offset some of the rising food costs. That largesse will go with the lower power costs from the free solar panels and batteries from scummo’s mob and enhance their sympathetic approach to governance.

  8. wam

    oops in the pool, lord, I remembered an important labor point to combat inflation for all living pollies and all widow/ers.
    A sleazy lawyer invented a scheme that not only avoided an extremely rare negative vote, but also created a term of reference that renders ‘independent’ meaningless. The pollies slickly shut out the parliament and hide any quango outcomes.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

The maximum upload file size: 2 MB. You can upload: image, audio, video, document, spreadsheet, interactive, text, archive, code, other. Links to YouTube, Facebook, Twitter and other services inserted in the comment text will be automatically embedded. Drop file here

Return to home page
%d bloggers like this: