C’mon, we’re better than this

Opposition Leader Peter Dutton made his Budget Reply speech last Thursday night.…

Promising the Impossible: Blinken’s Out of Tune Performance…

Things are looking dire for the Ukrainian war effort. Promises of victory…

Opposition Budget in Reply: Peter Dutton has no…

Solutions for Climate Australia Media Release National advocacy group Solutions for Climate Australia…

Understanding the risk

It's often claimed the major supermarkets would prefer to see tonnes of…

A Brutal Punishment: The Sentencing of David McBride

Sometimes, it’s best not to leave the issue of justice to the…

Climate pollution and petrol bills coming down as…

Climate Council Media Release AUSTRALIA IS OFF AND RACING on the road to…


It’s time we reckoned with what it means to become a corporatocracy.…

Plan B

By James Moore Every time there is a release of a New York…


Australia-China Relations: Down Under Squabbling

These are proving testy times for Australian-Chinese relations. Last week, Chinese authorities announced that an investigation would be conducted into claims that Australia has been using unfair dumping practices for its wine on the Chinese market. This was not what Australian winemakers wanted to hear, given that exports of Australian wine to China grew from AU$268 million in 2015/16 to AU$1.75 billion in 2018/19. While the investigation will take eighteen months, it risks going the way of a similar anti-dumping inquiry into Australian barley that was concluded in May.

On Wednesday, Wang Xining, the deputy head of mission of China’s embassy to Australia, spoke about various creases that had arisen in the relationship. Before the National Press Club in Canberra, he wished to “remove the shadows” that had been cast. “We are not trying to turn Australia into the People’s Republic of China … we’re not asking Hungry Jack’s to sell Chinese dumplings.” He suggested there was a confusion between foreign interference and foreign influence. Australia could hardly enjoy wealth, cultural diversity and intellectual richness “without accepting some foreign influence.”

Australia had also done its bit to hurt “the feelings of the Chinese people” by promoting an international investigation into the origins of the coronavirus. “All of a sudden, they heard this shocking news of a proposal coming from Australia, which is supposed to be a good friend of China.”

Response to his speech was miffed. Liberal MP Dave Sharma struggled to identify the “authenticity” of the message. He questioned Chinese willingness to “having open channels of dialogue,” given Beijing’s insistence on limiting contact with counterparts in Canberra.

Then came the freely expressed opinions of former Australian Defence Minister Kevin Andrews, whose private Zoom call with party members spoke of his “problems … with the most complete totalitarian regime that we’ve seen probably on the face of the earth from the regime of Xi Jinping.” Previous totalitarian regimes might have taken issue with that characterisation, not least of all because they would have deserved top billing for that honour.

But Andrews, along with a good number of Australian politicians, is rattled by the Oriental Menace. His grievances span “aggression in the South China Sea,” repression and incarceration of the Uighurs in “re-education camps,” and “a complete trampling of the agreement with China and the UK (to allow greater freedom).”

When such criticisms make their way to stage and podium, the crude, and not altogether invalid criticism from Deng Xiaoping comes to mind. National sovereignty, he insisted, came first but “talk about human rights, freedom and democracy is designed … to safeguard the interests of … strong and rich countries.” Countries keen to huff about human rights violations were often the very same ones infringing “upon the sovereignty of poor, weak countries of the Third World.”

Within Australia itself, lashes of concern are being directed at Victoria’s Belt and Road agreement with Beijing. The Morrison government has promised to introduce legislation that will grant the foreign affairs minister powers to review and cancel such initiatives. Foreign minister Marise Payne noted the current absence of legislation compelling states and territories to consult the Commonwealth “on arrangements with foreign governments.”

Keen watchers of this episode will note the stark inconsistency of positions taken by the Morrison government and his predecessors on such Beijing-related matters. On the one hand, the BRI nestling in an Australian state constitutes a threat, a tingling sensation of discomfort that has ministers and backbenchers up in arms. On the other, Australia has expressed approval in forming a partnership with China on that very same initiative, covering infrastructure projects in other countries. When the decision was made by the Northern Territory government to grant a 99-year lease of the Port of Darwin to China’s Landbridge Group, the Commonwealth kept its distance.

A club of anti-China enthusiasts is attempting to reverse, or annul, such agreements. Liberal Senator Concetta Fierravanti-Wells spoke in May of possibilities that evoking a national security emergency might give. Australia had to reverse its attitude to Beijing, which had “erred on the side of appeasement instead of standing up to, often bellicose and illegal actions.”

On August 26, China put more runs on the board of grievance with its customs department suspending beef exports from John Dee claiming it had found traces of the banned veterinary chemical chloramphenicol in sirloin pieces. According to a statement from China Customs, “In order to safeguard the food security of imported meat, China has informed the Australia side to conduct a comprehensive investigation on the company and report the result to China side.” This added to the suspension of four Australian abattoirs in May over those ever regularly cited reasons: non-compliance with health and labelling requirements.

Not to be outdone, the Australian government blocked the sale of Australia’s oldest family-owned meat processor and Japanese-owned Lion Dairy and Drinks, to China Mengniu Dairy Company. Both parties had already sensed that the Foreign Investment Review Board might be reluctant to grant final approval, and agreed to cease the process. It was certainly a departure from the initial confidence felt in February, when the Australian Consumer and Competition Commission gave its blessing, claiming the sale would not undermine local milk supplies.

But the times are awash with squabble and suspicion. Half-baked reasons are circulating about the next trade snipe, the next meddle and investigation. The Australian treasurer, Josh Frydenberg, had told Mengniu Dairy that “the proposed acquisition would be contrary to the national interest,” a view he claimed was “preliminary.” Nothing of detail was provided and certainly seemed at odds with the Morrison government’s approval of the AU$1.5 billion sale to Mengniu of the baby formula business Bellamy’s last year. National interest can be such a slippery concept.


Like what we do at The AIMN?

You’ll like it even more knowing that your donation will help us to keep up the good fight.

Chuck in a few bucks and see just how far it goes!

Your contribution to help with the running costs of this site will be gratefully accepted.

You can donate through PayPal or credit card via the button below, or donate via bank transfer: BSB: 062500; A/c no: 10495969

Donate Button


Login here Register here
  1. Neil

    It reminds me of the legal maxim, ‘he (sic) who seeks Equity, must do Equity’. I’m not convinced – here I refer to Max Blumenthal at the Grayzone – that this Uighur situation is what the West says it is; I would like to see evidence _Cf WMD. And secondly, Australia and the West have no democracy to boast about at this point, in my view.

  2. Jack Cade


    The Chinese say the Uighurs have been infiltrated by Isis or Al Qaeda operatives and need to be ‘dissuaded.’ They are certainly different from all the other minorities in China, but it’s a bit rich for the nation that produces the ‘persuasion’ techniques practiced in Abu Ghraib and Guantanamo to point the finger at ANY country. And the US is not prominent in its support of the Myanmar Muslims, who are certainly being treated considerably worse than the Uighurs are.

  3. mark delmege

    IMO this is not merely about SARS Cov 2, milk, wine, beef or barley but the whole shebang of the US war against China and our cheer leading role in support. Over at Pearls and Irritations a couple of Mike’s – one as author and the other as a comment put things into some perspective.

    I was disappointed with Labor’s P Wong’s contribution to the debate. When she could have made a positive contribution I thought she failed.

  4. Lawrence s. Roberts

    China is already changing its port facilities to cater for bigger ore carriers destined to come from South America and Africa.
    We are on our own. Our self-serving politicians have let us down again. We should be refining the ore here but that would incur government money as world finance would be gambling on the short term.

    Let me put nationalisation of the mining industry on the table. It is probably the only way that old coal areas will be rehabilitated and also to give the workforce a more gentle landing.

  5. RomoCharlie29

    So many hypocrisies on our part, and the Americans, in the reactions to China listed here, but also by Michael Pascoe in The New Daily. We are poorly served by our governing class, a bunch of economic illiterates who seem to think they are spending their own money in their support packages. The issue of value-adding, particularly in the minerals sector has been obvious for decades but the dig it and ship it lobby has had it all over gutless governments. If the debacle of C19 in private aged care homes has drawn attention to the need for real oversight and regulation, then we should also be looking at private sector job agencies and the Voc Ed and Training rorts. There are probably others. Only removal of Morrison and his bunch of duds offers any hope, though whether Labor would be better is moot.

  6. jamie

    Well the corporate coal/gas/ore no bill of Human Rights dig it up penal racist colony is in a bit of a fix isn’t it. Ha!! Spends hundreds of billions$$$$ to bomb murder and ravage Afghanistan, Iraq, & Syria at the behest of the u$a death machine, and now kneels down to accept u$a intercontinental missiles in the secret Payne/Reynolds Pompeous captiulation. Let the elders die it be. ZioJosh spewing lies lies lies. Incarcerate and torture First Nations’ children. That’s the PLAN. Plunder and descreate our sacred land for psychopathic billionaires$$$$$!!! That’s the PLAN!!! DOG EAT DOG THAT’S THE MOSCUM MURDOCH PLAN!!!


    PS: Bushfires just round the corner. How bout thats?

  7. A Commentator

    ByI recall this author saying, a couple of months ago, that Australia shouldn’t try to play with the “big boys and girls” in international relations, particularly relating to China***

    Maybe someone should tell India to be less interested in international relations too.


    ***Really, it’s a cringeworthy, the contemporary cultural cringe, when anyone suggests that Australia should know its place. And shamefully ignorant when an academic says that.

  8. Jack Cade


    But the ALP has supplied numerous retired politicians to the corporates they are supposed to abhor. And no doubt one or two more will jump ship soon to ‘spend more time with their family’ until the wording of their contracts with the big end of town have been finalised.
    And the word is that Flinders University has progressed to stage 2 of their COVID-19 vaccine trials, to thunderous disinterest from Scummo because none of his sponsors have invested in it.
    As Dr Spooner would have it, we are ruled (not governed) by a cower of shunts.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

The maximum upload file size: 2 MB. You can upload: image, audio, video, document, spreadsheet, interactive, text, archive, code, other. Links to YouTube, Facebook, Twitter and other services inserted in the comment text will be automatically embedded. Drop file here

Return to home page