The cycle must be broken
On the 10th August 1987 Australia announced the Royal Commission into Aboriginal Deaths in Custody. The final report and recommendations were signed on 15th April 1991. It has now been 30 years since those pages were signed and submitted for review by the government at the time. 30 years on we have lost almost 500 more people, without any new changes being brought into effect to minimise the high number of incarcerations nor the loss of lives. Minister for Indigenous Affairs, Ken Wyatt has often said; “The cycle must be broken,” but still we see no changes that would prevent these deaths nor reduce the number of individuals criminalised by the justice system.
Listening to an episode of The Quicky Podcast I was shocked to learn that Australians often suggest they are not racist, yet we are one of the few countries who do not adequately track racial profiling. These services do not release information regarding the racial breakdown of their interactions with communities. 2020 saw two instances where this data was released to the public. A judge in NSW requested police provide the information to the court. The data they produced showed that individuals of African or Middle Eastern background were 2.5 times more likely to be stopped than other nationalities. WA Police released data to The Guardian under the FOI Act showing police officers were 3.2 times more likely to stop and charge a someone of Aboriginal background than automated systems such as traffic cameras.
These two cases show a clear bias towards certain races, who have obviously been targeted by police officers. Tracking this data and releasing the information to the public would go a long way to providing accountability and correcting the racially discriminatory actions perpetrated by those who’s motto is to “Serve and Protect.” Similarly, courts releasing statistics on the sentences handed down to the different nationalities would show where one race is more heavily prosecuted than other races for similar crimes.
At the time of the Royal Commission the statistics showed 14% of the population inside the correctional system were Aboriginal People. Today that figure has more than doubled. We have lobbied for a National Indigenous Target for years, and governments have committed to do this but none have provided any information regarding how these targets will be reached. Many of the Aboriginal People I know and have spoken to believe the Royal Commission made no impact on their lives or their communities. They tell me there was no point in the commission because 30 years on and there are still no clear indicators regarding what recommendations were implemented or to what level they applied (in full, part or noted). In my own opinion the Royal Commission into Aboriginal Deaths in Custody is just another colonial document, as Marcia Langton has said about the Constitution.
Since the Royal Commission it has been revealed that all too many Aboriginal deaths in custody have resulted from a lack of duty of care. Such as the case of Ms Day in Victoria who died after being left fatally injured on the floor for three hours. Nobody has been held accountable for this neglect of duty of care. Now if this was the public sector each and every individual who had neglected their duty of care would not simply have been sacked; they would have faced criminal charges for the breach. Nonetheless, when the neglect to duty of care involves an Aboriginal or Torres Strait Islander Person who dies as a result of the justice system, nobody is held accountable. Not even the individuals who have been found guilty of these breaches. This to me is extremely telling, and it shows how much racial profiling occurs and is completely and utterly overlooked by the “powers that be” in this country!
Media have a great deal of responsibility for these issues. Take for instance the 11-year-old boy discussed on ABC’s The Drum on 12/4/2021. A newspaper headline showed on the episode that read; “Boys sad end to a life of trouble.” Instead of portraying him as an 11-year-old boy, media painted him as an intentional criminal: Listing a range of accounts of assault and other crimes such as burglaries that didn’t happen. At the time of his death he had a police curfew and needed to be home by 7 pm. The same night he died he had been at the Police and Community Youth Club. He took his own life that night in his bedroom. Twenty-four-years-ago he had faced racism and discrimination by the police, however an inquiry suggested it was not severe enough to have forced him to take his own life. He would be 35 if he had not been racially profiled by those who ‘serve and protect’.
Indigenous People are not innately criminal; we have something called the Lore of Obligation that obligates our people to protect regardless what it is we are protecting. This includes upholding legal requirements. However, we have faced unfair persecution at the hands of the Colonial System for 233 years. Changing the theme of these interactions should not be on mob; we are the victims in this instance. Responsibility lies with the justice system, as they are the ones who have created this narrative of criminalising the Indigenous Peoples. Perpetrators are responsible for making recompense, not the victims.
The fact that the NT Government have numerous occasions where SOLELY Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander youth have been in their detention centres should tell the country a lot. Instead, we are faced with racist remarks such as; “They should stop breaking the law and they won’t get arrested.” Or we have politicians like Amanda Stoker who laughed at Senator Dodson while he discussed the Aboriginal Deaths in Custody in the Senate. But when an Indigenous Person is arrested for something a non-Indigenous Person is not arrested for, then there is a clear issue in the system. More so in the racist opinions shared by Australians regarding the incarceration rates of the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Nations. Yes, this shame falls upon the heads of all Aussies, whether they care to accept it or not!
On the 30th anniversary of the #RCIADIC, this Govt is refusing to take responsibility for the growing crisis in deaths in custody. My questions to multiple agencies in #estimates revealed a lack of care and co-ordination. There must be national leadership on this issue. pic.twitter.com/shA1VZ3ak9
— Patrick Dodson (@SenatorDodson) March 26, 2021
Time and again governments create new programs that will further criminalise the Indigenous Nations of these lands. The history of the police with mobs has always included a large degree of racially discriminatory people and processes. Just this year QLD instigated a new program that will see youth walk around with electronic monitoring systems, instead of providing services that will prevent those youths from committing the crimes they have been found guilty of. This Government has chosen to further criminalise individuals over providing services to support these families and prevent the criminal behaviour from being a ‘thing’ for them.
Amy Thunig discussed on The Drum that Indigenous students are excluded from formal education in the form of suspension. In QLD 25% of fixed term and permanent exclusions are Indigenous children when they represent merely 10% of the school population. In NSW 25% of short or long-term suspensions are Indigenous children, who comprise simply 8% of the NSW student population. These statistics start in kindergarten and show how quick Australia is to hyper-surveil and over-punish Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people.
Ms Thunig went on to explain that NSW Government set up the Suspect Target Management Program, where they identified a list of individuals they thought may commit an offence. Nobody on the list had committed an offence but they suspected they would, which led the system to stop and interrogate these individuals for not committing any criminal activities. The youngest person on that list was a nine-year-old, which we all know is under the age of criminal responsibility in this country, yet the NSW Police Service still attended this nine-year-old’s home and integrated them. Indigenous People make up a total of 5.6% of the youth population in NSW, 51% of the children identified on that list were Indigenous. This is racial profiling – aka racism – on the part of the police system!
Before I go, let this fact sink in: since the Royal Commission into Aboriginal Deaths in Custody 474 people have died. That, statistically, is one person a month since the recommendations were released 30-years-ago. ONE A MONTH FOR THIRTY-YEARS! So before you claim we simply need to stop breaking laws, please think long and hard about the system you are defending in place of the lives lost!
How can Australians say human rights are high on the list of priorities in this country, when we clearly only value those rights for the colonial side of this country? Quite simply we cannot value human rights, not while we tell the Aboriginal or Torres Strait Islanders they deserve to die for crimes nobody else would pay with their lives for. Sadly, until Colonial Australia acknowledges this fact, they will continue to fail at equality.
I say it over and again, we are only the “Lucky Country” for Colonial Australia! We are only a first world country for the same portion of the population. Until we behave like a first world country we do not deserve the title!
Like what we do at The AIMN?
You’ll like it even more knowing that your donation will help us to keep up the good fight.
Chuck in a few bucks and see just how far it goes!
Your contribution to help with the running costs of this site will be gratefully accepted.
You can donate through PayPal or credit card via the button below, or donate via bank transfer: BSB: 062500; A/c no: 10495969
11 commentsLogin here Register here
White Australia has a Black History. Little Johnnie Howard created the ”Culture wars” to re-establish White Supremacists sentiments among Australian voters, and too many middle class Australian agreed. The problem is how do you justify the English taking over Aboriginal lands without compensation (rejected by the English Colonial Office in 1825 when Batman attempted unsuccessfully to pay for the ”Melbourne” land he was claiming) and the government sponsored genocide to establish and maintain European domination and destruction of the land by having inappropriate land use methods?
New England Cocky – I couldn’t agree more! We didn’t use flags because we still to this day have our own ways of acknowledging sovereignty – paintings! Did you know that 90% of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islanders were slaughtered in those acts of genocide! They only stopped in 1933 when the unions got behind mob!
There is also poverty profiling and if you are of Aboriginal descent, Middle Eastern appearance, or generally different looking, you can earn a double jeopardy. Just being poor is enough for extra attention, so if you drive an old car, walk at night, have no shoes, hang around with your mates because there is nothing else you can afford to do, or you live in a social housing area, you are subject to police scrutiny as well.
king1394: But, on the other hand, if you “drive a nice car” but don’t look like everyone else (not “white”), you are MORE likely to be pulled over! Then the assumption is that the car is stolen! Or the proceeds of crime!
This is true not only in Australia but in many other countries where the dominant population is “white”. Millions of examples are documented time and again, but seem to make no difference. Data is not relevant where prejudice is involved.
Ah! But we do behave like a first world country. Much of Australia aches to be like the USA.
In the USA young blacks are targeted for petty crimes. Walking on the grass, speaking out of turn and other dubious charges.
This saddles the young people of colour with a “criminal record”. So the next time they are approached for something equally petty, they already have a record. They are on the cops “books”. This enables law enforcement to paint a picture of “bad from birth”.
We are not far off this level of corruption in policing.
@Jennifer Michels: I think you may find that the genocidal attacks continued long past 1933, if local accounts in regional locations are correct. Skeleton Creek on the North Coast NSW for example..
Then followed the on-going discrimination by government agencies. For example, in about 1955 the Armidale City Council resolved that the local Naiwan people could build a ‘village’ of corrugated sheds to live in on the former Armidale City Dump/Landfill.
It took the election of the late Bill McCarthy (ALP) in 1976 to demolish these sheds and have the NSW Housing Commission build proper brick homes.
@Kerri: There is little doubt that many Caucasian Australians support many of the White Supremacy tenets that Little Johnnie Howard encouraged to remain in political power.
Kerri, Australia is at that same level of pettiness. I know an autistic Indigenous boy who at the age of 11 threw a pencil at his teachers because they triggered him into an meltdown (symptom of autism) by getting in his face & constantly touching him when his body could not tolerate touch. They rang the police who roughed him up & arrested him for assault – while all but assaulting him to make the arrest. They even used a knee on his neck in the same way George Floyd died from, and he was only an 11 year old boy.
It was an incredibly traumatic experience for him & now every time he sees a police officer he panics & runs in fear of them. Do they sit back & think oh maybe that young man is afraid of us? No they don’t. They chase him down & arrest him all over again. Drag him into the station & interrogate him to find out why he ran. He’s always so worked up they can’t get a word out of him as he’s in the middle of a meltdown.
He’s been charged more than once for running away in fear of the cops. How is that any different to walking on grass?
New England Cocky, Yes the genocides did continue past 1933, but that was the last officially sanctioned attempt with approval from Fed & Local Govt at the time. Others were done by individuals without government approval & were heavily covered up. Sadly, nobody was ever held accountable for the un-sanctioned genocides either.
This thread,as so often happens when we are discussing these matters, gets bogged down in the history of invasion and settlement.
As an old aboriginal lady said to me some time ago ‘ as long as we continue to look backwards, we will not go forwards. ‘
This dear lady has since passed on but her words ring true.
Terence Mills a better quote would be: “Those who fail to learn from History are doomed to repeat it.”
We must understand the foundations of our cultural behaviours, but not be bound by the past – after all most ‘tradition’ is little more than fossilised pragmatism.
“…the history of invasion and settlement.” is still being played out in Australia today, though from the scant attention which it is given by the MSM one would imagine that it has disappeared altogether.
Hypocrisy is the backbone of human governance and administrations.
Nearly five hundred people?
Starts to look like a war crime to me.