By Maria Millers
With the Spring Racing Carnival in full swing this week horses are the stars. These magnificent, powerful creatures have captivated people’s imaginations for centuries, from myths and legends they have left a significant mark in various contexts: warfare to literature culture and sport.
So when these animals show up in our dreams, they carry deep symbolic meaning that often represents raw instincts, sexual energy, inner power, or a need for freedom and escape.
In the realm of dreams, they come,
Horses with manes like waves of silver moonlight,
Hooves that scatter stardust, tails that sweep the night.
They carry us beyond the bounds of reality,
Into worlds unseen, unexplored, unknown. (Mystic Companions by Dan Higgins).
The relationship between horses and people is rich, deep, and ancient. Think Bucephelus Alexander the Great’s beloved steed or Seabiscuit, the American thoroughbred of unimpressive lineage that during the Depression brought hope to millions happy to see an underdog succeeding. And similarly, our own Phar Lap was a source of pride for struggling Australians. Nor to be forgotten is the bravery and loyalty of horses on the front lines providing companionship and strength to soldiers in past wars.
Horses have also played a major role in transport, food production and industry. Whether pulling the ploughs in the fields or working as pit ponies in mines. Not that very long ago milk was still delivered in some areas by a horse drawn vehicle.
In The Man from Snowy River, Banjo Paterson illustrates the bond that existed between Australians and their horses, portraying horses as more than just animals; they are loyal partners and trusted companions in a challenging environment.
“So he went; they found him later, at the bottom of the hill,
In a clump of trees and scrub, all gaping wide;
And the man from Snowy River never haggled at a hill –
For his horse could climb a mountain that an alpine goat would shirk,
And he counted on his horse, his friend, his only hope and work.”
This week as the Spring Racing Carnival unfolds reaching its peak with the Melbourne Cup there are mixed feelings abroad. Victorians are undoubtedly happy to enjoy a holiday, but not all see this event in a positive light.
The increasing commercialization of the event and the expanding international influence has in many minds make it appear as detached from the roots of Australian culture.
But for government and business the Melbourne Cup generates more economic benefit than any other sporting event in Australia.
Still the groundswell of critics is growing.
Foremost is concern for the welfare of the animals. Those in the industry will argue that race horses are the most pampered animals cared for by teams of, grooms, farriers, nutritionists, veterinarians, behaviourists and physiotherapists to make sure they are in peak health and condition.
Many like Australian philosopher and animal rights advocate Peter Singer argue that horse racing is ethically unjustifiable as horses are often subjected to significant injury and suffering primarily for human entertainment and profit.
There is the selective breeding and discarding of those that early show a lack of racing potential. And then there’s the practice of overtraining young horses often leading to injuries making them no longer profitable for racing. This raises disturbing questions as to what happens to them? Some are ’rehomed’ with families, farms or charities but the ugly fact remains that slaughter of thoroughbreds is legal in Australia and that is the fate of many.
For many the use of the whip is unacceptable. There are now restrictions on the use of the whip but it still allows the jockey to inflict pain when the guidelines only stipulate that the whip be used in a way that is humane and to avoid sensitive parts.
And horse injuries and deaths still occur regularly.
It’s worthwhile to remind those who justify extreme training and racing by believing that horses like their human counterparts are elite athletes and therefore happy to undergo rigours of training etc. The difference is that the human athlete made a choice to become one, whereas the horse was not given that choice.
“The horse is, like man, the most beautiful and most miserable of creatures, only, in the case of man, it is vice or property that makes him ugly. He is responsible for his own decadence, while the horse is only a slave.” (Rosa Bonheur, The Horse).
The economic boost of the Cup spans numerous sectors, including retail, hospitality, and tourism. It seems more and more that this is an event about corporate branding with so called celebrities, influencers and affluent socialites promoting outfits ranging from the extreme to the bizarre and dining and wining in magnificent marquees while the general public is confined to lawn areas and General Admission Stands. Often the traditional elegance of the past has given away to unfortunate fashion choices, excessive drinking and questionable behaviours.
Overall, while the Melbourne Cup is a celebrated event bringing people together, the social divisions are evident in the way attendees engage with the event, their attire, and the areas allocated.
While many participants and businesses involved in the Melbourne Cup profit, the racing clubs, sponsors, and betting agencies often see the most significant financial gains overall.
Overall, while the Cup might not consistently lead to the same high-frequency losses that everyday gambling venues do, it still represents a substantial risk for those susceptible to gambling harm, especially given the heightened media coverage and huge focus on the race.
For those who look forward to the Cup as their one flutter for the year, I wish you all the best of luck. But be mindful that behind the glitter and glam there is the reality And spare a thought for the horses.
An excerpt from At Grass by Philip Larkin reflects on the lives of horses after their racing careers, depicting them as they graze in a pasture, free from the pressures of their former lives.
Do memories plague their ears like flies?
They shake their heads. Dusk brims the shadows.
Summer by summer all stole away,
The starting-gates, the crowd and cries –
All but the unmolesting meadows.
Almanacked, their names live; theyHave slipped their names, and stand at ease,
Or gallop for what must be joy,
And not a field glass sees them home,
Or curious stop-watch prophesies:
Only the grooms, and the grooms boy,
With bridles in the evening come.
Maria Millers is the founder of The Woorilla Poetry Prize. The Woorilla Poetry Prize Event will be held at 2pm on November 17th at the Hills Hub. Delightful afternoon of performances, music and great food.
[textblock style=”7″]
Like what we do at The AIMN?
You’ll like it even more knowing that your donation will help us to keep up the good fight.
Chuck in a few bucks and see just how far it goes!
Your contribution to help with the running costs of this site will be greatly appreciated.
You can donate through PayPal or credit card via the button below, or donate via bank transfer: BSB: 062500; A/c no: 10495969
[/textblock]
Where men, money and animals come together, animals suffer.
Steeplechase, or jumps racing, is the most dangerous ‘sport’ for horses, far more lethal than flat gallops.
Banned in Qld in 1903, WA in 1941, NSW in 1997 and SA in 2022. Only Victoria continues to hold jumps events.
Victoria also continues to endorse the killing of wild ducks, along with SA, TAS and the NT, despite waterfowl populations plummeting by more than 95% over baseline counts a century ago, 99% of that [95%] decline within the last 40 years. Over the last ten years an average of 320,000 ducks were shot and killed each hunting season in Victoria, let alone the other three regions.
Human behaviour continues to demonstrate that it’s a very dangerous thing to be a wild animal in this country, with an estimated 10 million native mammals, reptiles, birds and other species killed each year by vehicles, as well as millions more by virtue of predators such as cats and foxes, along with incessant habitat destruction that accounts for millions more losses of individual creatures.
And with few exceptions, the people of this country are sleep-walking through this armageddon.
Profits before People- and horses. I think, underlying behavioral structures/issue that require a sort of gladiator scenario- the naked ape up still can’t live without a cognitive jungle of conflict and competition. Will we evolve?
Canguro’s comment on SA racing came in the wake of many fatalities for both horses and even riders over time, esp at the Easter carnival at Oakbank, in the hills. Easter Oakbank was sacrosanct, so it was suprising than in the end, the hurdless and steeples were let go of.
The industry contributes more than $1 billion in Federal and State taxes annually, and the economic value to the economy is estimated to exceed $5 billion per year. Australia has more racecourses than any other country in the world and the second-largest number of racehorse starters behind the USA Jumps gave jockeys and horses more work.
ps
Had a rest from darwin easter ’75 and took my dad and father in law(just retired) to oakbank our first bet was in sydney sizzler he was beaten by a nose but he was 100/1 so we had money for the rest of the day. Sadly on his 2nd day of retirement, my father in law died on the wednesday.
What a lucky farewell.