Questions to answer as live export cruelty charges to be dropped by WA Government
Australian Alliance for Animals Media Release
The Australian Alliance for Animals is today calling for an immediate inquiry following revelations by Nine newspapers that the WA Government intends to drop animal cruelty charges against the state’s largest live sheep exporter just days before a long-awaited trial was due to commence.
Emanuel Exports was charged with 16 counts of animal cruelty by the WA State Solicitor’s Office in 2019 following the public exposure of horrific conditions on several of its voyages to the Middle East, including the infamous Awassi Express, which led to the death of over 2,400 animals from heat stress.
The decision to drop the charges comes just weeks after Emanuel Exports was granted regulatory approval to reopen the live sheep export trade with the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia.
Alliance for Animals Policy Director Dr Jed Goodfellow said today’s revelations were shocking and the public deserved answers.
“These are very serious criminal charges regarding a matter of great public interest.
“To inexplicably drop the charges at the eleventh hour on the basis of ‘the public interest and the interests of taxpayers’ raises more questions than it answers.
“Is the government saying it is too expensive to uphold the law when it comes to animal cruelty?
“This sends entirely the wrong message to the WA community – it’s essentially saying that if a defendant has deep pockets, they’ll get a free pass on alleged breaches of the law.
“It simply doesn’t add up and that’s why we’re calling for the matter to be referred to the WA Crime and Corruption Commission for immediate inquiry,
“Australians were shocked to their core by the horrific scenes of sheep gasping for air while being trampled and dying in beds of their own faeces while sailing into the stifling heat of the Middle East,
“The fact that the exporter responsible for such profound suffering will not be held accountable is an affront to justice.
Despite the withdrawal of the charges, it is a matter of public record that Emanuel Exports voyages resulted in over 2,400 sheep perishing from heat stroke.
Exported sheep continue to face extreme conditions traversing the equatorial, Red Sea and Persian Gulf regions with over 70% of voyages since 2018 reporting heat stress.
A multi-million dollar, publicly funded trial to install air-conditioning units on live export vessels in 2019 failed to be effective in reducing heat and humidity.
“There is simply no way to export Australian sheep into the Middle East in a way that meets acceptable standards of animal welfare,” Dr Goodfellow said.
“The Australian Government must put an end to this misery as soon as possible by expediting its phase out of the trade once and for all.”
About the Australian Alliance for Animals
The Australian Alliance for Animals is a national charity leading a strategic alliance of Australia’s key animal protection organisations with a combined supporter base of over 2 million people. Core members include Animals Australia, Humane Society International Australia, World Animal Protection Australia, Compassion in World Farming, FOUR PAWS Australia, and Voiceless, the animal protection institute. Website: www.allianceforanimals.org.au
Like what we do at The AIMN?
You’ll like it even more knowing that your donation will help us to keep up the good fight.
Chuck in a few bucks and see just how far it goes!
Your contribution to help with the running costs of this site will be gratefully accepted.
You can donate through PayPal or credit card via the button below, or donate via bank transfer: BSB: 062500; A/c no: 10495969
4 comments
Login here Register here-
Baby Jewels -
Ron Hamilton -
leefe -
Terence Mills
Return to home pageYou’d expect this of Liberals but Labor? What’s the difference, these days? Liberals last. Labor second last…
That’s right. Liberal and Labor stand side by side as right wing capitalists. Communists are left wing (normal people that just want happy families and to work hard for a good life for everyone worldwide and socialist are somewhere in the middle towards the left. They have always pretended there is a big difference by calling Labour left wing as if we have a real choice.
Enough money, and you can get away with anything.
This country really needs a credible alternative to the ALP and LNP.
According to the official government website the federal government remain “committed to phasing out live sheep exports by sea”.
The government appointed an independent panel to consult with stakeholders and provide advice on how and when the government will phase out live sheep exports and a transition to boxed frozen and chilled exports principally to the Middle East (most Asian markets have already transitioned).
The independent panel provided its report with advice and recommendations to the Minister on 25 October 2023 (it doesn’t seem to be publicly available yet). The government is considering the report’s findings and recommendations as well as the next steps for the government and timing for the phase out of this trade.
https://www.agriculture.gov.au/biosecurity-trade/export/controlled-goods/live-animals/livestock/live-sheep-exports-phase-out
This AIMN article deals with the public prosecutor in WA dropping criminal charges against an exporter for alleged unlawful acts dating back to 2017 – as far as I can see there is no suggestion that the WA government was involved in making the decision to drop the prosecution which would, if true, be a serious offence, in breach of the separation of powers and a matter for the state crime and misconduct authority to investigate. As far as this observer can see this decision at state level is in no way related to the federal government’s policy to phase out the trade.
Incidentally, as New Zealand has shown and as the Asian market has demonstrated, chilled and frozen product is superior and preferred by consumers and actually delivers better returns to producers.