Election diary No 11. Wednesday, 16 February 2022.
The first thing to say about the National Press Clubs ladies’ speech day was that Albo turned up; Scomo didn’t.
1 In one of those moments you cannot manufacture, Grace Tame and Brittany Higgins at the National Press Club expressed themselves in terms that honoured their femininity. They articulated their anger in a manner usually reserved for the angriest of men. It’s the men who have to modify their behaviour.
Let’s hear it for these courageous ladies.
Conspicuous by his absence, the prime minister could have given the occasion the potency of his masculinity. He had the opportunity to display some leadership, but he seemed to belong to another era. Like Abbott, he allowed the opportunity to pass through to the keeper, reinforcing the point that it’s men who are the problem.
Sure, he would have had to experience the indignity of exposing his lack of understanding of just what women were telling him. But he could have made the statement that he cared and was prepared to listen despite the alleged embarrassment it would cause him.
Instead, again he paints himself as part of the problem and not the solution.
Tame and Higgins delivered what could be a final knockout blow for Morrison, labelling him an abuser. Now it’s up to us to ensure that the final blow is struck at the ballot box!
In a tweet, Barrie Cassidy, former Insiders presenter, described their appearance thus:
An exceptional moment in 2 speeches that were jaw dropping in their power, intelligence and emotion. Extraordinary how 2 people brought together by abuse will surely change the country. https://t.co/nqRGsOjiCY
— Barrie Cassidy (@barriecassidy) February 9, 2022
The ABC’s Dannielle Macguire and Georgia Hitch wrote an excellent summary of the two speeches at the National Press Club.
In my reading, listening on this subject, I must say that most people miss the point. That is that men are the concern. It doesn’t occur to them, so women have to tell it as it is. It is our actions that have implications for others. Some men have never grown up. It can be seen in every sphere of life, from war to rape. The rise of narcissism and inequality and the demise of compassion is a male trait.
Unfortunately, the audience at the press club was comprised mainly of females. Even male journalists failed to front up. Were they in their absence making a point, or were they too embarrassed to do so? Anyway, two better speeches you are unlikely to hear again. It was a moment in time when women of today told men of yesterday that they needed to change. Not today, not yesterday or tomorrow. But immediately.
Of course, Andrew Bolt had a different take on the event. Writing in The Herald Sun, he lamented that:
“There was “unbridled hate” for Prime Minister Scott Morrison at the National Press Club today, says Sky News host Andrew Bolt.
It comes as advocates for survivors of sexual assault and abuse, Grace Tame and Brittany Higgins, addressed the National Press Club in Canberra on Wednesday.
“Unbridled hate, not the slightest attempt to reach out to the Liberals to join in tackling an issue that should concern all of us,” Mr Bolt said.
Bolt would have his supporters, but obviously, he also misses the point. Reaching out to Liberals has no future in it. Given their record, it would be the last thing you would do.
[textblock style=”4″]
At some time in the human narrative … in our history, man declared himself superior to women. It must have been an accident, or at least an act of gross stupidity. But that’s men for you.
[/textblock]
2 Scott Morrison warned his ministers (as all Prime Ministers do) that disunity spelt political death. He told the party room:
“I’m going to lead, and I’m asking you once again to follow me to an election victory.”
After an all-night sitting and as dawn approached on Thursday, five Liberals ignored the prime minister’s advice and crossed the floor to vote against Morrison’s baby; the religious discrimination bill.
The show of faces was more extensive than expected and left senior figures somewhat bewildered.
News from the Senate was no better. They didn’t have the numbers to get its religious discrimination legislation through the Senate. Liberal senator Andrew Bragg also intended to cross the floor.
It wasn’t Morrison’s only problem. As per The Guardian, a “Fresh leak revealed Scott Morrison was rolled in cabinet over a plan to win back the renegade MPs.” Now, he was facing a boilover on the right.
The over-represented Australian Christian Lobby was so aggrieved it called for the legislation to be withdrawn.
Remember Morrison had told the Christian right after seeing same-sex marriage pass through the Parliament that he would give them protection. Religious discrimination would be Morrison’s major reform, the legacy of his prime ministership.
He also saw it as a potent political wedge against Labor as ever playing the political game. But the legislation failed to protect vulnerable kids. Once again, his political judgement was found wanting. It would greatly diminish his ability to raise the voice of religious discrimination in the coming election.
The wedge had become a reverse wedgie with a two-hand grip.
Scott Morrison has been rolled by his own cabinet, despite telling them that he was putting his leadership on the line in a bid to secure safe passage of his religious discrimination bill. Exclusive by @vanOnselenP. Watch @10NewsFirst at 5pm for more. https://t.co/78mDRgObzu
— Stela Todorovic (@Stela_Todorovic) February 10, 2022
Channel 10 and the Australian were reporting that:
“Scott Morrison was rolled by his own cabinet, after presenting them with a plan to save his religious discrimination bill by also putting a national integrity commission bill back on the agenda.”
3 By the end of the week, or should I say three years late, Peter Dutton sought to even the score by saying that the five (who crossed the floor) had given assurances. Any Government that takes 3 three years to pull some relatively simple legislation together doesn’t deserve to govern.
Dutton also raised the spectre of Labor being connected to China, bringing yet another scare campaign into focus.
4 Come Saturday, the headlines in mainstream media outlets confirmed that Morrison had suffered another horror fortnight of political chaos. The following day, all three journalists on Insiders were aggressive in their condemnation of our governance.
Here are some of the major headlines:
Familiar tune: Morrison opens up his home amid ‘kitchen sink’ strategy, but will it actually work? (The Sydney Morning Herald).
Scott Morrison says he ‘understands’ Canberra antivax protesters amid skirmishes with police (The Guardian).
Discriminatory ‘sword’ may spill Coalition blood (The Australian).
Why the Liberals will not dump Scott Morrison … but the voters might (The Sydney Morning Herald).
Our hard-ball next PM? Peter Dutton signed up ‘to play tackle, not touch’ (The Sydney Morning Herald).
The political week that ended in the toilet, literally (WAtoday).
Stood-aside MP Alan Tudge will recontest his seat, despite cloud of allegations (The Sydney Morning Herald).
5 George Christensen, the soon to depart extortioner of public funds, was found ripping off the taxpayer to the tune of $10,000 a month to feed like-minded nutters with conspiracy theories about “unelected global elites.”
https://twitter.com/choosing150/status/1490790644205645824
In August last year, the federal Parliament condemned Christensen after describing COVID-19 restrictions as “madness“.
And the promotion of anti-vaccination, of course.
6 If you come across the word Cakeism (as used in politics), it means “You cannot be all things to everybody all the time.” Or “you cannot have your cake and eat it too.”
7 Monday 14 February, The Poll Bludger reports Newspoll 55/45 for Labor.
“Newspoll’s second poll for the year records no change on the major party primary votes since the Coalition’s disastrous result a fortnight ago, but a decline in Greens support and Anthony Albanese’s personal ratings.”
[textblock style=”3″]
Previous post: I write because I cannot remain silent.
[/textblock]
[textblock style=”4″]
My thought for the day
Just because clowns govern us doesn’t mean it is a laughing matter.
[/textblock]
[textblock style=”7″]
Like what we do at The AIMN?
You’ll like it even more knowing that your donation will help us to keep up the good fight.
Chuck in a few bucks and see just how far it goes!
[/textblock]
