The Angertainer Steps Down: Rupert Murdoch’s Non-Retirement

One particularly bad habit the news is afflicted by is a tendency…

The ALP is best prepared to take us…

There's a myth created by the Coalition as far back as I…

On the day of Murdoch's retirement...

By Anthony Haritos Yes, we were cheap. And we were very nasty. Yes,…

We have failed the First Nations people

These words by Scott Bennett in his book White Politics and Black Australians…

Fighting the Diaspora: India’s Campaign Against Khalistan

Diaspora politics can often be testy. While the mother country maintains its…

The sad truth

Senator Jacinta Nampijinpa Price's comment that: ... she did not believe there are…

A tax incentive to accelerate diversity in Australia's…

Science & Technology Australia Media Release A new tax incentive to drive diversity…

It was all a con

By Andrew Klein I remember that as a teenager we had to…


Turnbull government a dead parrot as power-crazed Trump cuts loose.

It’s been a shocker of a holiday for a Turnbull government which slunk off to lick its wounds after being routed by its own ludicrous 2016 energy policy debacle – only to be rocked by MPs’ travel scandals and the debacle of the Centrelink Robo-debt-clawback debt extortion scheme which may, it seems clear this week, have a ninety per cent error rate.

It doesn’t help when The Australian National Audit Office reports that the Department of Immigration and Border Protection spent $2.2 billion without permission. Nor when Scott Morrison trumpets he’s, “putting Australia first”, but has to go to London to announce he’s helped us grow a $500 billion gross public debt; outspending Labor two to one.

But, look over here, Scomo’s got a beaut new trade deal up his sleeve, says The Herald Sun. Just as soon as the Brexit dust settles, he’ll be laying the foundations for a new trade agreement. Perhaps there will be stuff for backpackers who can also take in the washing in a transitioning economy based on services more than digging up coal and iron ore.

Much clearer, is the proposed mid-year export of George Brandis to London to get him out of harm’s way and to become Australian High Commissioner. It is being treated as an “open secret” at DFAT. Lord Alexander Downer who expected, at least, another term on the grounds that he is born to rule and that Daddy was Commissioner before me will have to be dragged kicking and scheming from the Australia House mansion by the usurper. At least with Crown backing, the Colossus of toads’ deposing of Downer should be less fraught than his demotion of a previous solicitor general.

Demotion is something the Coalition knows intimately, after its shock election result and its decline in opinion polls. As the Chinese Year of the Rooster dawns, Malcolm Turnbull and his government are already feather dusters.

Rude shocks continue. The Coalition of capons pulls its head out of the sand, only to be eye-gouged by newly proclaimed US Vandal-king, Donald the Red, a power-drunk, politically illiterate knuckle-headed tyrant eager to show he’s king of the playground at home and top dog on the world stage by abuse of his presidential executive powers.

Trump, the campaign blowhard, was meant to morph into a Republican pussy-cat. That was the Coalition plan; its reality-denying rationale for inaction and inertia secured by yet another Julie Bishop charm offensive- now exposed as woefully inadequate.

Instead, Trump is rushing to honour his threats including tearing up the TPP, banning Syrian refugees, closing the border to all Muslims and leaving Australia no “great and powerful friend” to cosy up to at the arse-licking end of the world.

The deal to re-settle, in the US, refugees from Manus and Nauru, struck under Obama, is also dead in the water, Labor argues, but, world leaders in Direct Action, trickle-down, the NBN, scrapping a carbon tax and other modes of reality denial, the government remains confident, the PM announces Saturday, deep within the Coalition’s virtual sinkhole, it has found a loophole “deep within” the President’s anti-Muslim executive order.

The loop-hole, said to have been inserted by a cutting edge PMC allows a case-by-case exemption to allow the US to “conform to pre-existing agreements” provided Trump understands any of it or has read his own executive order.

Heroically, Turnbull phones Trump Sunday, on the number he got from Greg Norman, to probe the inner incoherence of the nuanced and profound understanding that has characterised The Donald’s diktats so far.

Doing a typically magnificent job as back-up, Deputy Prime Minister Barnaby Joyce adds his own natty touch of policy incoherence and disunity. He tells 2GB listeners – the radio station that governs Australia – that it would not be the end of the world if the deal did not go ahead.

Finding his own loophole meanwhile, Loghman Sawari flies from Manus to Fiji, to seek asylum on the grounds of his certain persecution should he return to PNG. The 21 year old Iranian is the first to seek protection from Australia’s punitive offshore detention regime which has meant years of suffering beatings, bullying, imprisonment, illness, suicide attempts and being threatened by a PNG official. He fears that Trump will tear up the resettlement in the US plan.

Border Supremo, Generalissimo Peter Dutton has yet to comment – and won’t because operational secrecy trumps open and transparent government. Just imagine how the people-smugglers’ business model would benefit once people realised they could smuggle themselves DIY-style. Expect refugee advocates to be blamed for what is yet another indictment of offshore detention and evidence that Turnbull’s US resettlement plan is a cruel and dangerous hoax.

The ANZUS hoax is still intact. Trump hasn’t torn up the ANZUS Treaty yet, but given its nebulous wording only “to consult” he doesn’t have to. Turnbull’s wait and see tactics mean his government is flat-footed; floundering. Blind Freddy can see he’d be mad to expect any favours from a US President whose anti-Muslim ban is creating chaos around the world. He books a call for 9:00 am Sunday (5:00 pm Saturday in Washington) anyway.

Australia does receive from the US State Department a culturally sensitive Happy Australia Day message which claims that the US has “no better friend than Australia”.

If only the reverse were true. The message coincides with Invasion Day rallies involving hundreds of thousands of Australians in major centres throughout Australia which are generally reduced in the media to reports of “clashes” rather than for any statement they seek to make.

Barnaby Joyce helpfully adds “protesters should crawl under a rock and hide a little bit”, as he does his best to promote ignorance and intolerance from the top – doing his own bit, as always, to disgrace and dishonour the Coalition in the eyes of increasing numbers of Australians who would vote this mob out tomorrow if they could.

His government in free-fall in opinion polls – 46% to Labor’s 54% in Essential’s poll this week, Mal the Vaccillator, the PM of convenience, whose total surrender to the right has neither quelled rebellion, nor inspired followers, is in deep trouble. Adding to his fix, an outbreak of Trumpophilia – with some MPs already Trump-struck.

Scott Morrison vows to “put Australia first” while right wing nut jobs get out their dog-whistles and Barnyard Barnaby descends to rocks and stones. Never to be outdone in delusions of grandeur, Pauline Hanson is reported to believe she has a serious chance of winning government in the Queensland state election. Or hold the balance of power.

Or something very big, important, something just “yuge” whenever her Svengali, micromanager and political aspirant himself, James Ashby, gets around to providing that talking point.

Beastie-Boy Cory Bernardi and George Christensen, geed up by Trump’s public humping of democracy and all decorum threaten to come out publicly as anti-Halal 10 February at anti-Islamic Q Society’s fund raiser while sniper Abbott’s latest gibe is that the PM ought to stop talking about agility and show some. Somehow, Abbott’s taunt gets a result.

Rocked by rorting revelations, so serious Pythagorean numerologist Sussan Ley’s inquiry must be kept secret, and with no policy agenda for 2017’s parliamentary year, the Coalition digs deep within its existential absurdity to find its own, inner, dead parrot.

Monty Python’s dead parrot sketch is reworked as a live TPP no-one else can see – an invisible friend with benefits. Frantic for distraction, the PM pretends that Trump has not killed off the TPP. Behold! It is reborn; our Free Trade saviour. Bill Shorten must die for his “cowardly” and “gutless” lack of faith and his heresy in refusing the communion of holy free trade – and his allegiance to populist, protectionist, powers of darkness.

Novel? It is politics as usual in the asylum; a mad theatre of the absurd run by the inmates, largely for their own benefit with a few indulgent words of praise from captains of industry bankers and the odd media mogul.

A couple of Liberal shills are called in to attest to the TPP resurrection. There was still “a lot to be gained” from the TPP and “we intend to pursue that”, Mad Dog Scott Morrison, our Federal Treasurer and revenue problem denialist says mid-week from a UK where he has discovered the secret to housing affordability – as you do – is to stay in bed with property developers, an amazing breakthrough he and his PM call “increasing supply”.

Trade Minister Steve Ciobo, who recently revealed that he can’t tell a trade deal from a Grand Final, chimes in with a catchy “12 minus one” arrangement, a sort of reverse baker’s dozen, rather like leaving the US out of its own stag night.

Japan, on the other hand, still raw after being dudded over Abbott’s submarine building deal, sneers. The TPP is “meaningless without the US”. Pursuing the TPP is a “pointless waste of time” agrees Shorten.

But Labor becomes the whipping boy. For days Shorten is howled down, publicly flogged for being a “cowardly” wimp and a free trade heretic and not upholding a TPP that has expired – a TPP that never was. An alternative factual TPP. What’s going on?

Turnbull’s farcical TPP diversion is a desperate bid to wedge Bill Shorten as anti-trade or for being weak- and in yet another echo of Tony Abbott’s character assassination – just for being Bill Shorten – a slur in itself now, thanks to Murdoch media and Abbott’s Royal Commission show trial which have both helped demonise the Labor leader.

This week, Turnbull taunts Bill Shorten over the dead parrot of the TPP which anyone but gutless Bill, weak Bill – can tell is not dead but just resting, shagged out after a long squawk. Labor’s honesty is heresy, treason and no cojones combined, in the PM’s hysterical denunciation.

OK, it might be clinically dead – but it will prove a phoenix rising from the ashes of Trump’s trade treaty bonfire. Or Trump could change his mind. Or a re-jigged TPP will lead us to a fair bit of eternal prosperity for the time being.

In a post-truth Trump universe of alternative facts, no-one dare mention the truth. The TPP, like all other so-called “free trade agreements” is about trade protection. It is chock-a-block with lists of free trade exempt items such as digital goods and medicines. It seeks to increase copyright protection over these goods. Extend trademarks.

Australians would continue to pay more for these under the TPP. Leaked documents from the largely secret treaty, a lawyers’ picnic that was seven years in the making reveal that the TPP would extend US copyright laws over Australian businesses, hindering innovation and adding compliance costs, according to intellectual property experts.

In brief, one big lie inhabits another. Shorten is demonised for not valuing a dead TPP. It’s a bizarre contortionist performance from a frantic PM who is scaling new heights of absurdity in his will to convince us, against all evidence, that the dead parrot sings. How can he keep a straight face? Yet his resurrection dream is even sillier.

Not only is the TPP alive and well, with a quick re-jig and a few shanghaied new crew members from China, Indonesia, or wherever, we’ll be in easy street, rich beyond belief by rivers of free trade wealth trickling down from fat cat exporters. Pity no-one apart from Turnbull seems to see his point. Or would ever believe a Coalition promises.

Unlike Turnbull, however, Donald Trump seems to be keeping his pledges. Or his threats to tear up everything Obama achieved, everything progressive or enlightened or wise. So much to undo. So little time.

Certainly he is backing out of the TPP as promised as soon as he takes office. Most see this as the kiss of death. The US is a whopping 40% of the TPP which is less about trade than enabling big pharma, big tobacco and other US corporate interests to dictate to Australia and other nations how local politics best protects US investments. With a TPP, for example, plain packaging of cigarettes would fail. The investor state dispute settlement (ISDS) clause gives corporations power over its signatories; all sovereign states.

The other aim of the late, lamented TPP was strategic. It would balance China’s growing regional political and economic power. Act as a bulwark against the rise of the (not-so) Pacific Panda with its military installations in disputed territories and its muscular global diplomacy. Yet that TPP is not the make-believe TPP which our government wants resurrected.

To hear Turnbull or Ciobo spruik it, the TPP’s not about strategy or investment it’s all about trade, and not just trade but free trade, Amen. Look at all the deals that will go West if we walk away from the TPP at this stage. It’s bunkum.

In 2010, our own Productivity Commission found the benefits of the TPP to be negligible. No-one in government admits that TPP nations are already our trading partners. As for economic benefits, we didn’t need a TPP to have a resources boom from our trade with China.

Shorten ought to get real, Turnbull jeers. Any fool can see that the TPP is still alive. A quick ring around the neighbours and we’ll top up the numbers. Give the TPP skeleton the kiss of life. Put Humpty Dumpty together again. Get the gang show back on the road.

Of course, he’s got a lot to deal with – there’s a rift between the nervous nellies of the back bench who fear electoral annihilation through sheer incompetence and own goals of a cabinet you could drive a panzer tank division through. Or drag a Trump tower. Sideways. But his latest outrageous display is insane. Of course, there’s a lot on his disordered mind.

Factor in a damaging rorting crisis with the recycling of World’s best Greg Hunt, a fan of the US Health system, as Health Minister and a perfect, scrap-Medicare patsy. Blend in a complete absence of any plan or policy to speak of beyond tax cuts for the rich. Add a dash of Narcissus Trump who doesn’t give a toss for all our diplomatic grovelling, fawning and our mindless US-Alliance fetishising.

All he cares about is the size of his inauguration crowd and throwing his weight around.

Presto! Desperation is bound to break out. You might almost feel sorry for a PM who once had to say that he and The Donald were peas in a pod with their business backgrounds and their late entry politics – even if neither of these is true. Alternative facts, rule, OK?

We have come to expect the unexpected from a government with no real plan and less demonstrated competence – beyond a genius for turning crisis into catastrophe. Yet, as the year of the Rooster dawns, everywhere is chaos and cock-up. Trump-mania afflicts his crew, the new US president turns out to be mad, bad and dangerous to know, a monster intent on proving he’s boss at all costs. No wonder Captain Mal is showing a bit of strain.

But who would have thought he’d reprise the Monty Python dead parrot sketch in his madness- his manic quest to wedge Bill Shorten on the TPP; an ex-treaty, an agreement which even Shinzo Abe, never the sharpest knife in the sushi kitchen, can tell you is deceased.

Or could it be that the dead parrot represents the Turnbull government itself that is deceased, DOA at the beginning of 2017 parliamentary year; all over bar the squawking?


Login here Register here
  1. Ian Williams

    Thanks David Tyler……a brilliant and cutting summary of politics now!

  2. Ella Miller

    It was on ABC 24 not long ago that Trump will honour the deal made with Obama….I wonder what price was extracted?

    I find the first week of Trumps presidency frightening not just for the world but Australia.
    It has emboldened bigots, racists like Christiensen , Hanson and others to crawl out from “under their rocks” into the light and seem to be waking up racist views that till now have just been under the surface of the Australian society.

    I fear that there seems to be a similarity between what is happening now all over the world and the rise of Hitler.
    Then too the world slept, in disbelief and fear …..then…..

  3. David Tyler

    Yes, Ella, but Turnbull has yet to explain it himself. If you read the loophole, it says … Case by case basis. No indication of numbers or any time frame.

  4. Kate Ahearne

    David, Thanks for this.Wow, what a massive and sustained effort! Such a lot to worry about – but also lots of larfs, giggles and snorts, thank goodness. (A spoonful of sugar makes the medicine go down.)

  5. Pat Garnet

    I agree with Kate. Can’t read total article , tooo occupied
    laughing. Oh boy how much we need that,

    a good satisfying LAUGH. love it!!

  6. brickbob

    Brilliant stuff David, i like the part about the year of the rooster and Turnbull and Co as feather dusters,yes they will soon be a spent force for sure.

  7. susan

    Great article. It shows how much we need the media to just stick to the truth.

  8. Kronomex

    Judge Ann Donnelly in New York isn’t going to be a judge for too much longer after daring, and good on her, to stand up to The Donald about his repulsive immigration order.

    The sycophants and lunatics surrounding him will be going into overdrive to find some way of removing her as The Donald’s overwhelming arrogance, and fury starts to steam the window of the White House. It’s going to be interesting to see if he can resist spewing his bile over his mobile to show his displeasure (being polite here) about the judge.

    If they’re going to ship the balding coconut off to be the High Commissioner in London then who is going to replace…oh jeez, horrifying thought…could it be Arfur “Honest Arfur, the Used Water Board Salesman” Seenodonours is going to be the nest Attorney General?

    I’d like to say more about the asylum inmates that run (ruin?) the country but I want to do some reading so in closing, I think the following piece of music from the film Dark Man sums up the federal LNP wonderfully –

    Darkman: Carnival From Hell – Danny Elfman’s Music –

  9. brightr6

    such is life !
    as long as shorten survives so will turnbull and look at the smile on his face !there is no hope for the alp albanese should be leading the party ! shorten knifed rudd and gillard and is hovering over albanese cheated the so called alp new fair system! if albanese was leading the party at the last election he would be prime minister!
    mr turnbull so comfortable (why! shorten)

  10. David Tyler

    Kronomex, well-placed sources say it will be Christian Porter. At this stage. Even money.

  11. Craig Welch

    Wow! Seldom have I seen such ignorant ‘reporting’. Let’s start with the obvious:

    “Leaked documents from the largely secret treaty, a lawyers’ picnic that was seven years in the making reveal that the TPP would extend US copyright laws over Australian businesses, hindering innovation and adding compliance costs, according to intellectual property experts”.

    Largely secret? leaked documents? The entire, full text of the TPP was officially published a year ago. Why read leaked texts when a) they’re no longer accurate and b) the actual Agreement is readily available.

    TPP would extend copyright laws? Hardly, Australia pretty much aligned its copyright laws with the US when it signed AUSFTA.

    “With a TPP, for example, plain packaging of cigarettes would fail”.

    Plain packaging of cigarettes is already law, and ISDS cases against Australia and Uruguay have failed. But more to the point, the TPP *specifically* stated that an ISDS case could not be brought against tobacco related legislation.

  12. Peter F

    “The investor state dispute settlement (ISDS) clause gives corporations power over its signatories; all sovereign states.” David, thank you for this article. The ISDS in itself is sufficient reason to remain outside this ‘agreement’ Why is this not being given the publicity it deserves? To sign away our states rights in this way is nothing short of treason.

  13. helvityni

    They are all there, all ducks and roosters, even the haughty Steve Ciobo, and the earnest Mr Hunt…

    Only the hens are missing, those long holidays can be so exhausting, and now you got have your hair done and wardrobes renewed for the for the hard yakka of the new ‘working’ year… Life’s a bitch…

  14. helvityni

    oops, accidently sent the post before corrections, so sorry…

  15. Henry Rodrigues

    Ah David, what a way to start the week, a brilliant denoument of this utter utter useless corrupt government. And the comments were spot on too. You’ve said it and what a way you said it. Thanks.
    To the person who thinks Shorten is not the man to lead Labor, remember he got rid of Abbott, Hockey, Bronwyn, won Labor 14 seats, and has this dummy Turnbull so confused that he doesn’t know who his real opponent is and so ends up flailing at Shorten but never ever striking a blow.
    Craig Welsh…. whatever the pluses and minuses of the TPP, it is history. Just keep in mind, Australia with its small population, heavy dependance on exports of resources and very little or insignificant manufacturing would ever be able to get a good deal. Even our strongest sector, agriculture, got a bum deal. Better to conclude bilateral trade deals with similar minded countries in our region.

  16. David Tyler

    Craig, your response echoes the misinformation and spin published by big pharma and other corporate groups on the TPP- especially once the secrecy of the TPP was lifted. Are you a lobbyist?

    Correcting your comments is unlikely to shift your advocacy but I will expand briefly on secrecy, copyright and tobacco for all readers in the interests of accuracy.


    1. Your comment obscures the fact that it was kept secret during negotiation. Only when WikiLeaks published final negotiated versions of the TPP in October 2015 did public sentiment turn against it. The US trade representative Ron Kirk is on record earlier saying that the administration knew if it were to become a matter of public debate it would never be approved. The link below describes the secrecy imposed just on US Senators as an example.

    TPP would extend copyright laws?

    1. The TPP would create copyright terms well beyond the internationally agreed period in the 1994 Agreement on Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights (TRIPS). The TPP would have extended copyright term protections from life of the author + 50 years, to Life + 70 years for works created by individuals, and 70 years after publication or after creation for corporate owned works (such as Mickey Mouse).
    2. Digital locks: Escalate Protections for DRM (aka Digital Locks): Signatory nations would be compelled to enact laws banning circumvention of digital locks (technological protection measures or TPMs) [PDF] that mirror the DMCA and treat violation of the TPM provisions as a separate offense even when no copyright infringement is involved.
    3. Rewrites: countries like New Zealand would have to completely rewrite its innovative 2008 copyright law, as well as override Australia’s carefully-crafted 2007 TPM regime exclusions for region-coding on movies on DVDs, video games, and players, and for embedded software in devices that restrict access to goods and services for the device. In the U.S., business competitors have used the DMCA to try to block printer cartridge refill services, competing garage door openers, and to lock mobile phones to particular network providers
    4. Trademark provisions – in the Intellectual Property Chapter (18) extend trademark claimant powers to favour the current trademark holders.

    … the TPP *specifically* stated that an ISDS case could not be brought against tobacco related legislation.

    1. Article 29.5, ‘Tobacco control measures’, the “carve-out” you refer to provides only partial cover for the regulation of public health. The tobacco control carve-out has limitations, and substantial risks remain for other important public health policies.
    2. Without a complete carve-out, other TPP provisions could be used by the tobacco industry to exert undue influence. Concerns have been raised about the potential effect of many TPP provisions on the implementation of the World Health Organization Framework Convention on Tobacco Control – such as the ability to restrict tobacco advertising and marketing.

  17. Kyran

    “Novel? It is politics as usual in the asylum; a mad theatre of the absurd run by the inmates, largely for their own benefit with a few indulgent words of praise from captains of industry bankers and the odd media mogul.”
    Aren’t our media laws up for revisiting in March? Those silly little things, cross ownership, veracity, etcetera? talcum has hosted Fairfax, Newscorpse and, indeed, the supreme undead corpse, Rupert. Apparently, he hasn’t sought any counsel from the ABC. That would be a waste of taxpayer dollars. Guthrie is a shoe in.
    Politics, as usual, in the asylum. Thankfully, our media moguls will report everything.
    Thank you, Mr Tyler. Is it possible to seek asylum in an asylum? Take care

  18. Pat Garnet

    This is reminding me of the negativity about Margarine when it was first marketed. At this stage I prefer to let the good/bad times roll, and for sure we have NO idea what we are going to end up with, and NOBODY knows how to fix the catastrophe which will soon be upon us. All this banter about who knows what and those who can’t remember what they don’t remember makes for a pantomime of extraordinary entertainment.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

The maximum upload file size: 2 MB. You can upload: image, audio, video, document, spreadsheet, interactive, text, archive, code, other. Links to YouTube, Facebook, Twitter and other services inserted in the comment text will be automatically embedded. Drop file here

Return to home page
%d bloggers like this: