Scotty Goes To War Or Series 3 Of…

We've always all had the experience of watching the disappointing next series…

The Taiwan Foreign Policy Fetish

Australian foreign policy towards Taiwan, as things stand, is a distant fantasy…

James McGrath’s crusade against the ABC

When Queensland Senator James McGrath gave his first speech in parliament, he…

Scott Morrison lies here

Porky pies - St Gladys leaves the field to Scotty Two Thumbs That…

Totalitarian Cyber-Creep: Mark Zuckerberg in the Metaverse

Never leave matters of maturity to the Peter Panners of Silicon Valley.…

Morrison’s belligerence backfires as he bounces around like…

Scott Morrison was road-testing a new approach today.  Apparently, he is the…

Scott Morrison Meets And Beats Me Every Time!

Now before some PM gets litigious and tries to suggest that my…

Voter ID and dead cats

By 2353NM   If you are over 18 you will be legally required to…

«
»
Facebook

The Incredible Shrinking Prime Minister

Well, I managed to survive 2020, so I guess I should join all those reflecting on the year. However, rather than reflect on all the events, I’ve decided to reflect on one of my favourite topics: biases.

I don’t claim that I’m immune. As a fat, old white male who was born at a particular time in Australia’s history I’d be an idiot if I tried to argue that I was completely free of sexism and racism. The best I can hope to do is to view my attitudes through the awareness that, even though, I believe all men are equal from time to time, I’ll make a slip… Whoops!

Anyway, a large part of the year had me thinking about confirmation bias. This is where we only see the information and evidence that fits with our previously held views. For example, when Scott Morrison goes on a holiday, some of us complain that he’s left us in the lurch by disappearing again when we wouldn’t normally begrudge someone who’s worked so hard doing photoshoots a few weeks off every month. Whereas others find it endearing that he spent all weekend getting photographed building a chicken coop even if there are no follow-up photos of the chickens leading some to suggest that this was just a cunning stunt from a PM who’s nothing but a stunning… eh, marketing man.

In order to avoid confirmation bias, I usually try to swap the behaviour and the person around. As you may have gathered, I’m not a Morrison fan and his shit shouldn’t be hitting me. I wouldn’t describe myself as one of Labor’s True Believers and while I support action to save the world, trees and I are just good friends and you won’t find me hugging them. So when a particular politician does something that makes me angry, I simply ask myself how would I react if a politician I admire did it…

Ok, sometimes it can be tough to actually find a politician that I admire but that’s a whole other story. For the sack of argument, let’s pretend that I’m a great admirer of Tony Abbott and I’ve read a story about how a Labor politician had adopted a totally false persona in public but was a complete fraud. To counter my confirmation bias, I simple have to ask: How would I feel if Tony had done that? How would I feel to discover that he isn’t the complete lunatic that he pretends to be and he’s only been pretending to be stuck in the fifties to win the votes of the stupid? Why I’d be just as outraged, so I can attack the behaviour of the Labor politician, safe in the knowledge that I’d be just as critical of my hero, were it to be discovered that his public face was a complete fraud.

Of course, it can work the other way too. While I might dismiss the recent controversy over Abbott not being fined for cycling in the wrong area in Sydney and stopping for a coffee, how would I feel if Bill Shorten had broken the rules and the police argued that getting coffee was exercise? Would I be completely ok with it because those latte-sipping lefties don’t get any exercise apart from stirring their coffee and lifting it to their lips? Or would I be outraged that he wasn’t horsewhipped in public?

We saw a lot of confirmation bias with the treatment of the various premiers. While Labor premiers who shut their borders were panicking and faltering, Liberals who did the same thing were largely absent from the discussion.

And while Dan Andrews was nominated for canonisation by some, others felt that he was directly responsible for the deaths of 802 people. I couldn’t help remembering that when riots broke out on Manus Island a few years ago, it was nothing to do with the government and all the responsibility of the security firm, but in this case Andrews was responsible for every single death because he – or someone – made the decision to. use private security when we should have used the police or the ADF.

Anyway, I did find it strange that some of those who were calling for people not to allow the virus to shut down the economy because suddenly the mental health of the unemployed was something to worry about, were the same ones who were now concerned about the deaths. “Look,” they kept telling us, “it’s mainly old people dying and they’ve had a good innings, so if a few shuffle off early who cares?”  Then suddenly, the people who thought Andrews was doing all right were victims of Stockholm syndrome because they were ignoring the deaths.

I also found it strange that the ones referring to Stockholm syndrome were often the same ones who were calling for us to adopt the same approach as Sweden, although it may have escaped their attention that Stockholm is in Sweden.

Of course this is entirely consistent with one of the central tenets of politics in Australia: Labor are responsible for everything that happens when they’re in government because even if they had nothing to do with it, why weren’t they paying attention whereas the Coalition can’t be expected to be responsible because they believe that governments shouldn’t intervene in the economy unless one of their donors needs help. 

Yes, confirmation bias is hard to overcome. If I use Gladys Berejiklian as my final example, I have to ask myself would I be upset if the premier of my state had kept their relationship with a corrupt politician a secret, failed to declare various conflicts of interest, shredded documents and removed computer files that gave information about pork-barrelling, failed to make masks mandatory because well, it’s just more rules, isn’t it, told us that there’s no real concerns about behaviour that some consider corrupt because everybody is and failed to protect koalas?

Somehow I don’t think I’d be saying that they’re only human.

Like what we do at The AIMN?

You’ll like it even more knowing that your donation will help us to keep up the good fight.

Chuck in a few bucks and see just how far it goes!

Donate Button

 

10 comments

Login here Register here
  1. Gangey1959

    Happy New Year to all and sundry. Thank you to everyone at AIMN for last year, (may it soon pale into the mists of time), and may 2021 be the start of a great new Adventure for us ALL. So the mad monk has caught in the wrong part of Sydney on his bicycle? Wow. I thought that he had been transferred back to Britain, to help them with their negotiations with other people and stuff, so he’s come a long way for a latte. It must be good. He should have been in quarantine then, not pedalling his wares, but it’s a new year today and everything is soooo much better. At least half of Australia is not on fire.
    That can also be said of our pm too, but it’s early days, and I am ever hopeful. He is going on break soon, and being such a handy fellah, and there are those chooks………….
    It’s been so hard to tell reality apart from fake news or bullshit and lies , especially when the words have come from our political class. Surely the word “Veracity” appears somewhere in their Oath of Office, but again, maybe I expect too much, and as our gladys explained, “Everyone does it”. Mind you, if I woke up beside that mr maguire bloke I’d go out and throw myself under a bus, but then, I have standards. I don’t cavort with (other) bent pollies.
    These border closures are a bit of a wake up. So are the mask rules. It will be interesting to see which side of correct action voldemurdoch’s rat pack come down on after the festivities and firecrackers have subsided. Are masks such a necessity? I mean, really, do I have to, ALL the time? AGAIN? At least I got a Melbourne Storm one for Christmas.

  2. Kerri

    Too true Rossleigh!
    While ScoMo was claiming in parliament he would not take one single public servant away from dealing with Corona to work on a Federal ICAC, Dictator Dan was working daily on Corona and continuing his program of level crossing replacements.
    Now who says they can walk and chew gum? Or for Scottyfrommarketing walk and chew strawberries.

  3. Josephus

    It is a small comfort to be reading an evidence based book showing how humans in power have over the centuries lied and made self serving propaganda to inflate their reputations and cover up their disasters. Plus ca change.

  4. Kronomex

    I think you mean The Incredible or Iniquitous or Insidious (I prefer the third word) Shirking Prime Monster when you talk about Saint Scotty of the Marketing.

  5. DrakeN

    As the ‘Great Bard’ wrote, Josephus, ” ‘t was ever thus.”

    As I continually maintain we, as a species in constant evolution, remain steadfastly many millenia in arrears of our scientific and technological advances.

    Primitive survival instincts so remain so deeply embedded long after the need for them that they act like a ‘sheet anchor’ on our communal and social evolution.

  6. Jean

    A great article as usual Rossleigh! And to those 5 of you who have commented – what a great start to 2021, a great laugh and agreement with your collective wisdom – Safe, Healthy and Happy New Year to you all!

  7. Carina McNaughton

    Roseleigh you are an excellent writer and I look forward to your wisdom in 2021. AIM keeps me sane knowing others are out there who share my political view and challenge it too.

  8. cheryl tonkin

    Carina, I agree with you whole heartedly.
    I often feel I don’t belong on this planet with so much of the crap that is happening.
    However the likes of others here on AIMNN and you give me hope. I’m often challenged with disbelief at what so many are willingly to go along with unquestionably. Thank you all.

  9. Peter F

    I can confirm that I agree with all of the bias I interpret in your article. No wonder I like your work.

  10. Wonderer

    Rossleigh and commentators above you’ve made my day! The Incredibly Shirking Tosser does raise fundamental (pun intended) conflicts in me.. What TF?? Why TF?? How TF?? amongst them. Not particularly highbrow, but we appear reduced to the lowest common denominator by this purile administration. Thank you all for your intelligent, erudite words.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

The maximum upload file size: 2 MB. You can upload: image, audio, video, document, spreadsheet, interactive, text, archive, code, other. Links to YouTube, Facebook, Twitter and other services inserted in the comment text will be automatically embedded. Drop file here

Return to home page
%d bloggers like this: