My Land

By Khaled ElomarI reflect on my childhood in a war-torn country (Lebanon). The…

Oh the irony

One of the production team behind The Political Sword regularly attends a trivia night…

Exhuming Franco: Spain’s Immemorial Divisions

“Of course there’s one Spain. If there was another, we’d all be…

A Climate of Opinion

By John HalyThe battle for climate change mitigation is euphemistically referred to…

Border Protection Hypocrisy

Come by boat and you will be denied entry to Australia for…

Morrison's Bluff

Back in September 2014 a young man died in a Brisbane hospital…

Our politics is not reality TV?

"Politics is not a reality television show," scowls ScoMo, in a cameo…

The people have spoken

By Stephen FitzgeraldThe rich get richer and the poor get poorer! With…

«
»
Facebook

The Culture Wars

The Liberal Party cultural wars are having a detrimental effect on the rest of us. Here are two examples.

Without rehashing old news, Australia had a functioning carbon pricing and emissions trading scheme around 5 years ago. It was canned by the Abbott government after mounting the mother of all scare campaigns about $100 lamb roasts and the town of Whyalla being wiped off the map. Abbott’s then Chief of Staff, now a member of the right-wing mafia that promotes their ideological claptrap on Foxtel’s Skynews after dark, admitted later that the scare campaign was exactly that, a scare campaign without any basis in fact.

The ALP recently launched its energy policy for the 2019 Federal Election. The framework of the policy was partly pinched from the Turnbull LNP Government — the ‘National Energy Guarantee’. It is probably clever politics however history tells us that this watered down ‘least-worst’ policy was formatted specifically to stand a chance of getting the legislation through the Liberal and National Party rooms, rather than the Parliament or even addressing some of the needs and wants of residential and commercial energy users. It didn’t get up because the usual suspects determined to change the Prime Minister instead. The ALP policy from years ago was a better mechanism for reducing carbon emissions as there is a direct correlation between emissions and cost — something business understands.

As the ALP policy was released, the posturing from the Luddites in the LNP commenced again. As Katherine Murphy observed in The Guardian

The energy minister, Angus Taylor, by way of riposte, bunged on a high-vis vest, stood in front of a smelter in Tomago, and talked about Shorten having to nominate which burping cows he would cull, which, for a person of Taylor’s intelligence and technical expertise, must feel about as close as it comes to End Times.

We’ve been here before: the hyperbolic carry on, it’s all pretty tired.

The thing is that Taylor, as Energy Minister, should know better. More forms of renewable energy are being commercialised all the time. It wasn’t a ‘world first’ when the then ALP South Australian State Government chose to accept Tesla’s offer to construct a very large battery, connected to the electricity grid.

So, how did that work out? Pretty well actually, as we discussed in January this year. In fact it worked so well that Victoria purchased a couple of Tesla batteries last March. If Taylor still has any doubts, maybe he should talk to his South Australian party colleagues who took over the state government during the year.

The South Australian government will launch its Home Battery Scheme in October, which will offer South Australians subsidies of up to AU$6,000. In the wake of the government’s announcement, [Sonnen] the German storage provider has revealed plans to manufacture up to 50,000 battery storage units at the former Holden site in Elizabeth, creating hundreds of jobs.

Ooops! Clearly the truth isn’t getting in the way of this story. The issue is that reducing emissions of CO2 into the atmosphere is essential for our kids and grandkids — who at the current rate of environmental change (ignored by the LNP government) will be unable to live in a large part of Australia in decades to come. It could be worse — a number of Pacific Islands could disappear altogether! Now that is worthy of a scare campaign.

The dux of St James’s College in Brisbane’s inner-city Fortitude Valley graduated a week or so ago with a number of academic awards, high achievement in her Year 12 subjects as well as successful completion of two University level subjects while still at school. She wants to be a doctor and on the face of it, she has every right to believe she could be successful in attempting the demanding University course.

Except it won’t happen unless she can get a scholarship. The dux is a Sri Lankan asylum seeker, Soumi Gopalakrishnan, who arrived in Australia on a fishing boat around four years ago. The problem is that the LNP Government policy has determined that Gopalakrishnan and her family are here on asylum seeker visas. Asylum seekers are considered to be full fee-paying international students. Full fee students have to pay for their course (in this case over $100,000 per annum for the next five years) annually up front.

Gerry Crooks, the Principal at St James, said

“The school has obviously played a very significant part in getting them to where they are, but it’s been a privilege for us. I think they’ve given the school far more than we could ever give them as a family,”

For the record, St James is a ‘Catholic Co-educational Secondary College in the Edmund Rice tradition’ and, as well as offering free education to Gopalakrishnan, provided a public transport card for travel to and from school. A day after ABC chose to publish the story of Soumi Gopalakrishnan, a number of people and organisations had offered to assist her financially to attend University.

In contrast, our narrow minded, mean and vindictive government, currently lead by Morrison, who proudly shows off his bizarre ‘I stopped the boats’ trophy to the media will happily look the other way when illegal immigrants arrive by plane and overstay their visa, which actually is a crime. He and his government apparently don’t have a problem in bullying and victimising for political purposes those who attempted to arrive or settle here over the past five years with the perfectly legal right to claim asylum according to the 1951 UN Convention signed by then Prime Minister and Liberal Party ‘demi-God’ Robert Menzies.

And there is still some doubt that anything Morrison did to ‘stop the boats’ had any effect in any case — the number of people who were prepared to attempt to arrive in Australia by boat was declining, months before Abbott and then Immigration Minister Morrison conceived ‘Operation Sovereign Borders’.

Yes, both the power generation wars and the drawn-out war on refugees are fear-based campaigns. Hopefully the Victorian State election plus recent by-elections in Wentworth, Braddon, Longman and so on will give the conservative parties in Australia the final realisation that fear and scare campaigns that have stood them well since Menzies was warning about ‘reds under the bed’ are now useless. People clearly aren’t ‘buying’ the ‘Whyalla wipe-out’ or refugees are all ‘gang members in the making’, preferring to support plans and visions for the future. Unfortunately (for the Liberal Party), sections of their ‘broad church’ are too involved in their own cultural wars to see the wood for the trees.

What do you think?

This by 2353NM article was originally published on The Political Sword.

For Facebook users, The Political Sword has a Facebook page:
Putting politicians and commentators to the verbal sword – ‘Like’ this page to receive notification on your timeline of anything they post.

There is also a personal Facebook page:
Ad Astra’s page – Send a friend request to interact there.

The Political Sword also has twitter accounts where they can notify followers of new posts:
@1TPSTeam (The TPS Team account)
@Adastra5 (Ad Astra’s account)


7 comments

  1. Karen Kyle

    The Sri Lankan student has got a scholarship.

  2. wam

    I replied to the 3 labor pollies on my page, who shared the policy, asking whether they had batteries and, if so, whether barry o’sullivan gets 50 batteries or whether xenophon gets one or 13 as part of retirement.

    Don’t expect an answer.

    I may have missed the reasoning and mea culpa of the greens for voting with the rabbott to sink the wong/turnbull carbon price but who remembers that??

    I think there were many students more worthy than the rabbott’s daughter and many who could have got the scholarship given to gopalakrishnan.
    She will study for nothing and Australian students will study for debt. Grist for the mill of anti-asylum seekers.

    Does anyone here question why sri lankan tamils did not travel the short few kilometres to the tamil homeland for safety rather than the thousands of kilometres to Australia??

  3. New England Cocky

    The moonscape of coal mining is not seen from Point Piper or the redneck Cronulla insular Peninsular so it dos not exist, but the wind turbines at Lake George are almost bigger than the egos of Liarbral politicians so must be imperfect.

    Naughty AIMN, publicising the success of the SA Tesla Battery storage that Turdball ranted against. Slap on wrist with wet tram ticket!!

    The NSW Liarbral Party is very pleased to assist the communist Chinese PRC government with their external migration and settlement programme for aspiring hard working Chinese citizens. The Baird NSW Liarbral Notional$ misgovernment has offered to facilitate Australian citizenship to all North Asian investors who purchase a residential property in Sydney and live there for at least three months a year for four years.

    And Menzies worried about “Reds under the beds”????????

  4. helvityni

    I saw Soumi Gopalakrishnan on the Drum: a very bright girl wanting to study to become a doctor, her English was better than that of many a Aussie kid…no, not good enough for Dutton and co, go back where you came from…

    We have NO problem with brown, yellow or black foreign students entering our universities as long as they come here with stash of dollars….

  5. helvityni

    oops, saw her name and jump to comment…thank you ABC.

  6. totaram

    Wam: Which “homeland” of Soumi are you referring to? Did you mean Tamilnadu in India? She would have been put into a refugee camp there. Perhaps you don’t know. Try to be a little better informed.
    Oh, the “scholarship” she got is not from the govt. surely? It is from various donors. But I agree that local students should not have such a high HECS debt.

  7. Bronte ALLAN

    Sadly & all so very true! This inept, lying, obscenely over-paid, so-called “liberal” mob HAVE to go! And the sooner the better! Whilst I think Labor will be far better when next in power, they have a few “things” to “sort out”. Such as any further Adani coal mine crap being still discussed or even allowed to proceed, & the vexed issue of these poor bloody so-called “illegal immigrants” (?) not being able to settle here in Australia–the classic example of just how vindictive small minded this current liberal mob are concerning this excellent young Sri Lankan woman who it would seem would be an excellent choice to be a Doctor–but will probably finish up being deported along with her family. After all, we CANNOT “allow” these pesky bloody “illegal immigrants” to stay here & prosper can we? BASTARDS, are the lot of them in this bloody Federal liberal party!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Return to home page
Scroll Up
%d bloggers like this: