After telling me the way that it was, he concluded with, “Don’t think I’m racist or anything!”
I replied, “Gee, I expect that I am. I’ve grown up in a country that endorses predominantly white Anglo-Saxon attitudes. I don’t see how I can avoid some of that rubbing off on me.”
He looked at me.
“I know that I shouldn’t be, and I try to notice if I’m being racist, but I’ll bet that some the views and values that were around as I growing up affect the way I view things.. Still, the points you were making about the apology to the stolen generation strike me as quite reasonable. LIke the bit about people thinking that they were doing the right thing. So long as a person thinks they’re doing the right thing, there’s no need for an apology. It’s only when people knowingly do the wrong thing that you should apologise. Sort of like speeding because you’re in a hurry and having an accident, no need for an apology because you believed that you were doing the right thing by trying to get home as quickly as possible…”
“What the f*ck are you talking about?” he interrupted.
* * *
From time to time, some Tony Abbott supporter will post a comment along the lines of me being a Labor-supporting looney, as though being a member of the Labor Party automatically disqualifies you from an opinion.
Pointing out the fact that I’m not a member of the Labor Party and have criticised them in the past doesn’t seem to matter. The next assumption is that I’m a supporter of The Greens.
You see, unless you support the Liberals and Tony Abbott, their logic goes, you must be biased.
Normally, I just laugh such things off or put truly outrageous arguments back. Or just thank them for their intelligent contribution and say how nice it is to hear that people are reading what I write and actually thinking about it – it’s gratifying to know that I’ve changed someone’s mind. Their abuse when they tell me that I haven’t changed their mind and that latte-sipping lefties like me should be taken out and shot enables me to tell them that I’m about to have another Chardonnay – which in case they haven’t heard is making a comeback. Probably thanks to Tony Abbott.
But lately the debate on the ABC has made me truly worry about the state of some people’s mental health.
Let me see if I can give you my perspective. Of course, it will be biased. Everyone is, because everyone has a different perspective. By sharing perspectives, we can work out whether one’s perspective is similar to everyone else’s or radically different. If the latter, why? What experiences have lead one to question the orthodox view? And through this process, we gain greater understanding and greater perspectives.
* * *
All right, stop the bleeding heart stuff, next you’ll have us all singing “Kumba Ya”.
Why are you complaing about alleged ABC bias, didn’t the Murdoch Press attack the Labor Government ceaselessly?
The Murdoch Press is allowed to criticise the Rudd/Gillard/Rudd Government because it was truly incompetent – the “worst ever”.
How do we know this?
Well, the Murdoch Press told us.
Isn’t this showing bias?
No, it’s just stating the facts!
Isn’t “worst” an opinion?
Well, the Murdoch Press is privately owned, why shouldn’t it be allowed to express an opinion – are you trying to stifle free speech?
No, but on the ABC last week…
The ABC! It’s left wing bias has to be stopped.
Didn’t you just say that the media should be allowed to express an opinion?
The privately owned media, the ABC is taxpayer funded – it shouldn’t be biased
Yeah, but what’s the evidence of bias?
Their presenters often disagree with the Murdoch view. They never have a right wing perspective, as Josh Frydenberg said on ABC radio last week, backing up the point Piers Akerman made on “The Insiders” a few weeks ago.
Aren’t they a right wing perspective on the ABC?
Yeah, but they’re the exception.
Well, there’s a weekly show on ABC radio where a member of the IPA debates a more left-wing person on the events of the week.
Why couldn’t the IPA person debate without another leftie being there?? And where’s the right wing equivalent of Philip Adams on the ABC?
Philip Adams, the millionaire who writes for The Australian? Is he the most extreme example of the left on the ABC?
That just shows that the Murdoch Press give a variety of views! The ABC needs to sold.
* * *
Of course, perhaps Howard’s appointments to the ABC were an attempt to ensure that it had no bias. Let’s see, there was his close friend, Donald McDonald, as well as Janet Albrechtsen and the “anti-blackarm- band” campaigner, Keith Windschuttle. Balanced appointments there! And Michael Kroger, ex-president of the Liberal Party.
Now, that should have helped provide some balance, I would have thought. Or was the culture so entrenched that they somehow thought that these people might be showing a bias of their own, rather than realising that – like Murdoch – they had an implicit understanding of the Truth, and any disagreement displayed an entrenched bias and a refusal to recognise the Truth.