My Thoughts on the Week That Was
1 It’s difficult to criticise Labor’s proposal to impose the so called Buffet Tax on the rich when the Australian Taxation Office had found that in 2011-12 75 Australians earning more than $1 million a year had paid no tax at all. In fact combined annual incomes of those millionaires was $195 million, but through elaborate accounting tricks, the super-rich 75 had been required to stump up just $82 in total.
2 Research shows that Federal Coalition member’s annual expenses are on average $90,000 per head more than Labor MPs. Even allowing for the higher costs of incumbency it is an astonishing figure. No one doubts the validity of claiming expenses but this really has to be sorted out. Joe makes thirteen trips to his farm and Bronwyn attends Mirabella’s wedding all on the pretext that they were on government business. “The age of privilege is over” said Joe. “Crap” said Tony.
3 One of the regrets of my life is that in all probability Australia will not become a Republic in my lifetime. But Shorten is right to aim for 2025. And if you could make it sooner I would be immensely happy.
4 Bill Shorten is planning equal representation of the sexes in Parliament. Did he consult with the Minister for Women?
Sunday 26 August.
An observation:
“We exercise our involvement in our democracy every three years by voting. After that the vast majority takes very little interest. Why is it so?”
1 Last week at the Premier’s retreat the PM appealed for a calm measured debate on the GST without any scaremongering. Sounds reasonable except he continued his scare campaigns on Asylum Seekers and Climate Change.
An example of this is Dutton’s announcement that if Labor won the next election hundreds of thousands of asylum seekers would invade our shores. We deserve better than these fools.
2 Australia remains the only developed country yet to announce what plan it will take to the global climate summit in Paris. So let’s not have any of these ridiculous scare campaigns. It should be pointed out that Labor has not actually announced a Climate policy and that despite criticising Labor for not modelling its policy-in-progress, the Coalition can’t point to any modelling of its own Direct Action policy because it has never done any – not when it was in opposition, nor when it was in government. During the last election, if I recall correctly, Abbott said he just wanted to have a crack
3 The cost advantage of non-polluting energy is rapidly increasing. Wind is already the cheapest, and solar PV [photovoltaic panels] will be cheaper than gas in around two years, in 2017. Wind will continue to decrease in cost but solar will become the dominant source in the longer term.
4 Speaking of leadership the latest Morgan survey reveals that Abbott is supported as Liberal Leader by only 13% and Shorten as ALP Leader by only 12%. The Libs prefer Turnbull by a whopping margin and Labor prefer Deputy ALP Leader Tanya Plibersek.
5 It just won’t go away. It has now been revealed that TAXPAYERS footed a more than $21,000 bill for Warren Truss to give a speech explaining the virtues of tightening the government belt and reducing expenditure after the controversial 2014 Federal Budget.
It’s our money, folks.
6 All things considered it’s been a good conference for the leader.
Monday 26 July
A poem on the theme of domestic violence.
Maria, I called
I awoke with a throaty dankness Of alcohol overindulged Detestable stupidity And unmitigated sorrow
The why of it deserted me Memories vague but real I had committed a sin Of unforgiving evil
Then my conscience Spoke with morose meaning I had hit her a coward’s punch Destroying her exquisite smile
Maria I called to the silence But it prevailed God I said as if to mock my Self hatred
I pissed and staggered Through my regrets To the kitchen The stench of myself hit me
Where was she and The noise that children make Regret insinuated itself On the absence of love
She had written with miseries ink Just three words “The last time” on pristine white I cursed the grog but
Pathetically I sought the Next bottle of my degeneracy And took it to bed Contemplating the me I used to be
John Lord
1 Last week the PM was full of praise for a debate, without scaremongering, on the issue of the GST. It seems however that scaremongering is ok on climate change and it has begun already. An ETS is a tax he insists with the same enthusiasm he had for a leg of lamb or wiping towns off the map before the last election.
We all might ask though just what it is they are using to fund their nonsensical Direct Action plan. Answer: YOUR TAXES.
Then yesterday afternoon Malcolm Turnbull cut through Abbott’s slogans and semantics dominating the climate policy debate – pointing out that all policies to push low-emission electricity generation come at a cost to households, including the ones the government supports, and that the cost of renewables is falling. He went on to correctly talk about the costs of whatever scheme is adopted. The Coalition has never revealed its costings beyond its present scheme.
I repeat: “We all incur a cost for the upkeep of our health. Why then should we not be liable for the cost of a healthy planet”.
Remember the “historic and ambitious” climate agreement between the US and China, when Tony Abbott was left out in the ‘coald’?
Asked where the deal left Australia’s climate change policy, the expert adviser to the former government Professor Ross Garnaut said: “Exactly where it was before the US-China announcement – up shit creek.”
2 I do wish someone amongst all those Labor supporters who so detest Bill Shorten and his Asylum Turn Back policy would show me their alternate so that I might gauge the difference. The question always arises. What would you do?
3 Morgan Poll: L-NP support has slumped 3% to 46% cf. ALP 54% (up 3%) on a two-party preferred basis as the travel expense ‘misconduct’ surrounding Parliamentary Speaker Bronwyn Bishop’s incorrect use of taxpayer entitlements continued to impact negatively on the Government.
Tuesday 28 July
1 Bronwyn Bishop’s office claims she has to keep secret her meetings in Albury on the weekend she claimed travel expenses to attend Sophie Mirabella’s wedding. Sniff test, lie detector test, pub test. Take your pick.
2 Goodness, all the talk yesterday about more women in the Coalition ranks. Don’t they realise they have a minister for women and he also happens to be the Prime Minister. Why isn’t he taking some action?
3 This week’s Essential Poll and Survey sees Labor back on 53% and the Coalition on 47%. What can be read into it? Well this far out from the next election so many things can happen that you cannot view it as an indication of how people will vote. It’s only an insight into how people are thinking at the moment. It is a measure of this Governments unpopularity though that they have never headed the Opposition since the election.
This is what they thought of Bronwyn Bishop and the expenses saga.
25% think she should stand down while her expenses are being investigated, 19% think she should resign as Speaker and 24% think she should resign from Parliament.
34% of Liberal/National voters think she should remain as Speaker – 25% think she should resign as Speaker or from Parliament. A majority of Labor voters (59%) and Greens voters (55%) think she should resign as Speaker or from Parliament.
On Electricity costs
51% think their electricity bill over the last 12 months has increased, 33% think it has stayed about the same and 9% think it has decreased.
There were not substantial differences by voting intention or demographics – although Labor voters (58%) were a little more likely to think it had increased.
On the impact of the Carbon Tax.
More than 60% of voters think the former Labor government’s carbon price had no effect, or only a small effect, on electricity bills. Just as Abbott tries to rerun a cost of living scare campaign against Labor’s pledge to re-introduce an emissions trading scheme.
On Tax Reform
There was strong majority support for forcing multinational companies to pay a minimum tax rate on Australian earnings (79%), increasing income tax rate for high earners (63%) and removing superannuation tax concessions for high earners (59%).
There was strong majority opposition to increasing the GST (65%).
Wednesday 29 July
Posted my piece Where Did all his Readers Go?
1 Alan Jones opining about the character of Aussie rules player Adam Goodes. You have to put it in perspective of course. Goods is a champion player, champion human being who does a lot to further indigenous culture and represent his race. He is an ‘’Australian of the Year’’ and a fine one. On the other hand Alan Jones is a detestable human who delights in demining people. And he accepts paid millions to do so. How someone of such little character can judge someone with so much stretches my intellect somewhat.
2 Senior ministers, it seems, are ‘ropeable’ over the Bronwyn Bishop’s scandal saying it is damaging the Government.
Some charity should suggest an admission charge to the public gallery for the next Question Time to raise funds. Pressure is mounting on Bishop to resign but she won’t. Abbott is unlikely to force her instead relishing an all in brawl with the Opposition. In the meantime we can all sit and ponder just how it is we are being governed.
It would not surprise if today she says the dog ate her expenses homework-twice.
Who tweeted this?
After 2 interesting tram trips last night now on the 109 on Collins St to Sth Cross to get the train to Geelong to visit . . .
An observation:
“The simplest way to turn the profession of politics on its head would be to demand they tell the truth”
3 There is something cringe worthy about politicians delaying the inevitable. Abbott is doing everything possible to delay a vote on gay marriage. It’s not like it’s something new that requires more debate. The public has let the public know their feelings and they should act accordingly. All he is doing is making his Government more disliked than it already is.
Thursday 30 July
Bronwyn Bishop’s gratuitous empty apology to the Australian people on the Alan Jones (where else) program was too little too late. It does nothing for the public’s perception that politicians are openly rorting the system. She has further demeaned the position of speaker if indeed that is possible. Her bias as speaker is acknowledged by both sides of the political spectrum, as does all sections of the media. Her behaviour has reflected on all members of parliament and the Prime Ministers failure to dismiss her is yet another example of his lack of qualities as a leader.
Her credibility is now so tainted that she could not possible command the respect of the Parliament and its members.
The Leader of the House, Christopher Pyne, may well seek to protect her, particularly in question time, but an already tarnished, childish excuse for a demonstration of democracy will be further diminished.
There was a time when our Parliament exhibited some collective dignity and personal integrity. Abbott seems to have so trashed the conventions and principles of our Parliament that it no longer conforms to the traditions of the Westminster system.
A midday thought:
“Less informed voters unfortunately outnumber the more politically aware. Therefore, conservatives feed them all the bullshit they need. And the menu generally contains a fair portion of untruths”.
Friday 31 July
1 Has Mike Baird become our de facto PM. Firstly he makes the running on a debate for an increase on the GST. Something you would expect an incumbent PM to do. And yesterday he took on a plea for people to stop booing footballer Adam Goodes. In the meantime the leader of the nation remains silent on the issue.
Midday thoughts
1 Two issues dominated the week. Firstly the Adam Goodes’ saga occupied all genres of the media and many morally unqualified commentators opined their ignorance. It will be the subject of my next piece for THE AIMN.
2 Bronwyn Bishop continued to dominate the headlines and this morning Gerard Henderson was on News24 defending her. The point is this. Her performance as Speaker on any level of judgement has been abysmal. The expenses issue is simple the catalyst in calling for her resignation.
My view hasn’t changed. Bishop should resign and write her memoirs. I’m sure somebody MIGHT be interested.
Even today the PM said this:
“She is obviously deeply remorseful, anyone who saw her on television yesterday would know that she is a very, very chastened person indeed”.
Can someone tell me the medical term for delayed reaction?
And this is the week that was.
Malcolm Turnbull had the last word without saying a thing.
13 comments
Login here Register hereTodays Reachtel poll continues the trend of 2PP 53:47 to Labor. However Bill Shorten is once again preferred PM 55:45 over Abbott. Amazing that ALP have led in polls consistently since December 2013.
if some of the Govt front and back benchers live in hope of being in the next Parliament, they will need the earth to move to get there.
Careful, David, southern Queensland experienced an earthquake this week. Don’t give them any encouragement.
Another good wrap up, John.
Let’s not let Abbott’s and Joyce’s travel rorts and Hockey’s scams slip under the radar.
Nowra has become the epicentre of the storm over Speaker Bronwyn Bishop’s travel expenses after revelations she hired a $6000 private plane to fly her the two and a half hours to attend a fund raiser.Mrs Bishop was in Nowra late last year at the invitation of federal member for Gilmore Ann Sudmalis.Already facing calls to resign over the cost of a chopper flight from Melbourne to Geelong which she has had to repay, the Daily Telegraph newspaper is this morning claiming leaks from Liberal party sources that Mrs Bishop spent even more on the flight to Nowra to attend a fundraiser in Berry a fortnight after the chopper ride.
Source: http://www.2st.com.au/news/shoalhaven-news/85631-nowra-in-the-spotlight-over-speaker-s-travel-expenses
Shoalhaven News
© 2ST
Thank you, both to John Lord for another excellent article and to Roscoe for the update.
Bronnie’s payback looks like escalating into a very hefty sum.
I note that madam probationary speaker’s belated (and, I suspect, entirely insincere) apology was made to a biased commercial shock-jock with a proven history of prostituting his ‘opinions’ and repeatedly disseminating falsehoods (as well as having publicly endorsed the idea of murdering our then PM by drowning at sea).
I also note that she referred to her chopper jaunt to a party fund-raiser as ‘inexcusable’, unacceptable’, ‘ridiculous’, that it cost the public ‘a lot of money’ and ‘it looks wrong’, but also stated that it was all within the rules of political entitlement.
What does this say about the current rules?
I would not be surprised if a few others were examining their expenses and quietly paying them back.
Let us elect M.P.s who are not bent. GetUp could do the how to vote cards. The corrupt state of the present parliament would be a good time to block supply. Would The Greens & Indies go for it?
On you Midday Thought, John – conservatives also expend an inordinate amount of energy on feeding the bullshit. Not to say the left isn’t guilty too, but they don’t show anywhere near the guile in doing so.
I would prefer Penny Wong as leader to Tanya.
@Andrew…Penny would have to move to the HOR from Senate. However can’t see it happening either way, Will. Shorten is well ensconced
as leader and with a string of policies which has the Govt on the backfoot, caucus will be happy.
I have strong feeling, the apparent awful boat turnaround is to quote Baldrick, a cunning plan. What we see now, is not necessarily what we will get. Plus given firmly in control as Govt, the closing of Manus and Nauru will follow.
Just a hunch, but my 35 yrs journalist experience, gives hunches warm fuzzys. We will see.
Amid the furore over Bishop’s latest outrage and the non appearance of the PM in the debate on racism in our once fair land an event of immense importance for our collective future has been playing out in Hawaii. I refer of course to the supposedly final negotiations on the TPP deal for corporate colonisation of everything.
Happily the trade ‘representatives’ failed to agree and we have some more time to stop this thing; but it is sad that it got totally overwhelmed by the two biggest stories of the week.
Despite the lies from our supposed negotiator at the TPP talks, the fossil Robb, that the deal is 98% done and dusted and finale is days away, BBC and respected Japanese NHK English service report there will be no deal or further talks for weeks? (maybe months.)
That is bad news for Abbott and the Govt who are desperate to keep the details secret until its signed.
Just what are they so scared of us knowing about this so called, ‘good for the country’ windfall?
http://aftinet.org.au/cms/trans-pacific-partnership-agreement-tpp-tppa-2