Going Global with NATO

Regional alliances should, for the most part, remain regional. Areas of the…

Whatever it takes

By 2353NM Some years ago, a plumber was telling me when they came…

Australian War Memorial needs to own Australian frontier…

By David Stephens Proper recognition and commemoration of the Australian Frontier Wars at…

Chegg, Cheating and Australian Universities

The note on Radio National’s Background Briefing on the morning of July…

By the People and for the People: a…

By Max Ogden and John Lord One of Australia's most vexing questions is…

We Are In Total Agreement With The 43%…

Good morning, today we have a representative from the government-in-exile, Shadow Minister…

Fire, Flood and Famine

Sounds Biblical? As it should. Man's inhumanity to man also features. Talking to a close…

Whither Constitutional Change?

Within a very short space of time, we are going to be…


Manus: Turnbull’s time to act

By Terence Mills

The agreement that Kevin Rudd signed with the PNG government in 2013 includes the provision:

“Commencing on the day of announcement, any unauthorized maritime arrival entering Australian waters will be liable for transfer to Papua New Guinea (in the first instance, Manus Island) for processing and resettlement in Papua New Guinea and in any other participating regional, including Pacific Island, states [my bold]. Papua New Guinea undertakes for an initial twelve-month period to accept unauthorised maritime arrivals for processing and, if successful in their application for refugee status, resettlement. This program will be for 12 months and will be subject to review on an annual basis through the Australia-Papua New Guinea Ministerial Forum.”

The important provision in this agreement, and one which PNG have frequently referred to, is the resettlement provision that allows for resettlement in any other participating regional, including Pacific Island, states. This is where the meeting today between NZ Prime Minister Adern and Prime Minister Turnbull will be critical to breaking the Dutton confected impasse currently playing out on Manus Island. Former New Zealand Prime Minister John Key initially made an offer to take 150 of these refugees as a gesture of good will toward Australia and to allow the Abbott and now Turnbull governments to save face and start to dig themselves out of the hole that Dutton’s obstinacy has got them into.

It is likely that Adern will renew that offer today and Turnbull would be well advised to accept it as it may very well be the path to breaking this vindictive stand-off which seems to have become personal to Dutton. Turnbull should ignore Dutton’s perverse rationale that if any of these refugees go to New Zealand they could, after five years residency, become New Zealand citizens and armed with an NZ passport seek to visit Australia: it just makes no sense and smacks of desperate politics. Does he have the same irrational fears about those few refugees who have made it to the USA and who will undoubtedly achieve American citizenship in due course?

The problem that Turnbull faces continues to be the intransigence of the right-wing of his party who are already warning him not to accept the New Zealand offer when it comes. This opposition has little to do with refugees and resettlement strategies and more to do with the right-wing showing the Prime Minister who’s running this country: for Turnbull this is an opportunity to assert his authority and challenge the strangle-hold that the Right have him in. Will he seize the opportunity or buckle as he has in the past? We shall see.

If the meeting today can start the process and a path for properly and humanely resettling the men from Manus Island we then need to turn our attention to Nauru which has tended to be ignored in recent times, principally as a result of the limited access and media bans imposed by Nauruan authorities at the request of the Australian government.

Malcolm, the future of these unfortunate people is in your hands, please don’t flick-pass it back to Dutton and his cronies, they won’t respect you in the morning!

 148 total views,  2 views today


Login here Register here
  1. John O'Callaghan

    Was anyone that gullible to even entertain the idea that Turnbull would agree to the offer from NZ? …. i mean the bloke has form as a gutless wonder and a Master in the art of self presevation, and would push his Grandmothers wheel chair over the cliff with her in it if it obtained a positive outcome to himself and his cause!!

  2. Florence nee Fedup

    The offer was 150 per anum. Would have taken 600 by now.

  3. Glenn Barry

    With the resident malevolence Dutton and the LNP aspirations to use Manus and Nauru for political gain, of course they are going to prolong matters as much as possible.

    Question is, at what point does it become feasible to have perpetrators charged by the International Criminal Court or other applicable judicial body

  4. paul walter

    A government of cranks. Hanson rules. Even our old friends the Kiwis are baffled.

  5. Terry2


    That’s correct, it was 150 a year. So we could at least have resettled 600 by now but what then would the LNP have to whack labor over the head with.

    It seems Turnbull has spurned the offer from New Zealand and has added insult by saying that he will first allow the Americans to choose which of the refugees they want and then New Zealand can have the rest. Jacinta Adern has every right to withdraw her goodwill gesture which may very well be what Turnbull and Dutton want.

  6. listohan

    Why doesn’t Jacinta just offer 150 visas to selected detainees and cut Malcolm out of consideration? Australia claims no responsibility for these people when it suits.

  7. Terry2


    This was raised in an interview on the ABC with a NZ Green : as I understand it, your idea would require a request from the PNG government which could be vetoed by Australia as it is not legally the case that PNG have any standing in this fiasco beyond being used as a political football by Dutton.

    As far as I can tell, Australia is morally and legally responsible for the care and well being of these people.

  8. srs21

    Australia is now morally bankrupt

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

The maximum upload file size: 2 MB. You can upload: image, audio, video, document, spreadsheet, interactive, text, archive, code, other. Links to YouTube, Facebook, Twitter and other services inserted in the comment text will be automatically embedded. Drop file here

Return to home page
%d bloggers like this: